Philip II - a pen portrait

Court fashion, a love of birdsong and the pressures of being a king are some of the subjects discussed in letters between Philip II of Spain and his teenage daughters. Janet Ravenscroft explores the human side of one of Europe’s most powerful Renaissance monarchs.

Philip II (1527-98) was the eldest son of the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V (1500-58), on whose abdication in 1556 he inherited control of Spain and its empire. In 1581, when Spain was united with Portugal, Philip left for Lisbon and remained in the country for almost two and a half years. It was during this period of absence that the 54-year-old king began writing to his daughters in Madrid, the princesses Isabel Clara Eugenia (1566-1633) and Catalina Micaela (1567-97), who were nearly 14 and 15 years old respectively when the correspondence began. 

To the outside world, Philip presented himself as the archetypal Catholic monarch: one who controlled his emotions and actions, as befitted the head of a dynasty that believed itself to be divinely appointed to rule God’s earthly domains. It is unsurprising that the image of Philip that persists is the one that he so studiously maintained throughout his reign: the grave, pious king captured in numerous portraits. But Philip, like all monarchs, had a private side that was only revealed to his family and closest companions. A study of the Portuguese letters allows us to catch a glimpse of the private man behind the public persona.

The king’s 38 personal, handwritten letters addressed jointly to his daughters were never intended to be read by anyone other than his children. No official copies were made for the royal archive and they survived only because Catalina Micaela took them with her to Piedmont after her marriage to Charles Emmanuel I of Savoy in 1585. They are held at the Archivio di Stato in Turin. Sadly, we have only one side of the correspondence because Philip burned his daughters’ letters once he had replied to them ‘so as not to be loaded down with more paper’. Although this destruction may give the impression that Philip was unsentimental about his children, it is clear that he loved his family. 

There are numerous references in the earliest letters to Philip’s eagerness to see his sister, the Empress María of Austria (1528-1606), who was then on her way to Portugal via the court in Madrid. Assumptions that monarchs are unmoved by the dispersal of their families for dynastic reasons are challenged by Philip’s evident affection for his sister. He frequently expresses his impatience to see María and is envious that his children in Spain will see her before he does. He asks his daughters whether they think he and María still resemble each other ‘as we used to, especially around the lower lip’, a reference to the famous Habsburg jaw; whether she has grown fat or thin; and which of them looks older. When Philip eventually meets María he tells the girls that he is delighted, as they may well imagine, ‘it being 26 years since we last saw one another, and then only twice in 34 years and only for a few days each time’. In honour of her arrival, Philip changes from his usual sober garb into a satin suit and decorative cap. 

Clothes are a frequent topic of conversation between Philip and his daughters. They discussed the dress of relations and the attire of people in Portugal, such as the baggy linen trousers of the 300 bare-chested oarsmen from the royal galleon and the dark blue habits worn by an order of monks at whose monastery of Santo Eloy the king and Albert attended mass. It is clear that the girls occasionally quizzed their father about fashion at court. Philip reports back that the ladies in his sister’s entourage carried smaller fans and wore shallower ruffs and less expansive skirts than the huge hooped dresses, or verdugadas, worn in Madrid. He also advises his daughters on their own clothes, conceding that they could wear gold with their black dresses at a forthcoming wedding, albeit in moderation – the girls were still in mourning for the death of their stepmother, Anna of Austria, who had died during an influenza epidemic in 1580. 

There appears to have been some gentle rivalry between the princesses and María’s daughter, their cousin Margarita, whom they met in Madrid. The focus of this was the girls’ height, appropriately enough given that being tall was a factor in the conceptualisation of the ideal, aristocratic body. In response to a comment about the girls’ comparative sizes, Philip warns his daughters against pride:

You must have grown a lot, as they tell me that you, the elder are taller than her [María] in chapines [raised shoes]; and you, the younger are taller than your cousin [Margarita] who is older than you, but don’t be conceited about this as I believe it is because she is very short rather than you being tall. 

A fortnight later he asks the girls to send him their exact measurements and those of an unnamed brother, adding that he would much rather see all his children in the flesh. When this letter was written in March 1582 the surviving siblings were: the heir, Diego Félix (1575-82); the future Philip III (1578-1621) and María (1580-83). Philip had already lost three children: Don Carlos (1545-68), his son by María of Portugal (1527-45); then Fernando (1571-78) and Carlos (1573-75) by his fourth wife, Anna of Austria. It is therefore understandable that the health and welfare of his young family is a perpetual concern for the absent king. The baby, María, was born just a few months before Philip left for Portugal and, after a year away, he remarks that he would barely recognise the younger children any more.

Perhaps the most touching passages are those relating to the development of the younger children, such as María’s first steps and first teeth ‘which must be in place of two that I’m about to lose’. Also poignant are Philip’s messages to Diego Félix, his short-lived heir:

You say that your brother would read better if he took more care. Remind him that when I go (as it pleases God), he must be able to read and write and tell him that when he can write I will send him a writing desk from India ...

In addition to the desk, he later sent his son a rather more exciting gift: an elephant from the Portuguese viceroy of India.  

As part of his princely education, Diego Félix (like his sisters) was taught Portuguese so that he would be able to communicate with his subjects. Other appropriate skills for a Renaissance prince were dancing and drawing. Philip writes approvingly of a horse drawn by his son and promises to give Diego books on painting. Philip was a great patron of the arts and the person who developed Spain’s first royal portrait gallery in 1562. One of the portrait’s many functions in early modern Europe was to act as a substitute for an absent loved one and portraits of the children were eagerly exchanged between branches of the Habsburg family across Europe. These ‘likenesses’ enabled Philip to see the development of his offspring, and disparities between the painted image and the living model were debated: 

My sister tells me that his [Diego Félix’s] portrait is not good and that he looks better [in reality] and that the portrait made before this one was superior. It seems to me that he has grown, although his appearance has not improved.

The king and his daughters regularly enquire about each other’s health and there are numerous references to fevers, blemishes, purging and bleeding. When Diego Félix died aged seven and his brother Philip became heir to the throne, Philip wrote that the young prince should not have his portrait painted while he was looking weak and pale. Undoubtedly Philip’s concern was two-fold: that of a father for his son and of a king aware of the negative political consequences of depicting an unhealthy heir. 

Princes Diego Félix and the future Philip III by Alonso Sánchez Coello, 1579. The letters provide an insight into aspects of the lives of Philip and his children that would not normally be known by anyone outside the inner circle. For example, they reveal that Isabel Clara Eugenia had a terror of thunder and lightning and that Diego Félix was frightened of the devils in Hieronymus Bosch’s paintings in Philip’s collection. The king’s passion for hunting is already public knowledge, but the letters also reveal his love of nature, especially of flowers, gardens and birdsong, about which he writes frequently. The correspondence also introduces us to the entertainers and servants who went with Philip to Portugal, chief among whom is Magdalena Ruiz (d. 1605), an elderly servant and companion who was much loved by the royal family. Not long after his arrival, the king tells his daughters that ‘Magdalena has a great desire for strawberries and I of nightingales, although they can sometimes be heard from one of my windows’.

It is perhaps not surprising that Magdalena was chosen to accompany the king as she had been employed by the Habsburg family for decades and had lived in Portugal in her youth. On the other hand, she had evidently become rather irascible in her old age and frequently chastised the king. In January 1582 he reports that she doesn’t seem to be so cross with him but that she is ‘thin and old and deaf and half senile and I think it is all down to drink’. Whereas this passage has been used by historians as evidence of Magdalena’s drinking habits, what is more remarkable is Philip’s absence of criticism for his servant. As someone categorised at court as a loca or ‘fool’ (she was eccentric but neither insane nor a dwarf, as has been claimed), her lack of decorum and liberty of speech would be acceptable. However, it is clear that Philip and his family were very fond of Magdalena, whatever her ‘official’ role. 

When Philip goes to greet the Empress María, Magdalena is there too. Afterwards, Philip tells his daughters that ‘Magdalena is going around very happily with my sister, albeit in a tatty taffeta gown, which is my fault because I haven’t given her anything, as she hasn’t ceased to remind me’. María was reportedly shocked by Magdalena’s appearance, but otherwise found her ‘the same as ever’, a remark that dates her presence in the Habsburg family back some 30 years at that point, the empress having left Spain in 1551. One reason the old servant and her peers were so central to the royal family was the continuity of companionship they afforded in an environment where individuals were habitually divorced from their families for the good of the dynasty.

Magdalena ‘and others’ were expected to write to the children when Philip didn’t have time, in effect acting as unofficial chroniclers of the royal sojourn. Despite Philip’s wishes, Magdalena corresponded infrequently, sending apologies to Isabel Clara Eugenia and her sister through the king. In one letter Philip adds a note to say that Magdalena had been spending time watching black slaves dancing rather than writing to the princesses. However, she did correspond and in his next missive Philip remarks that ‘Magdalena did well in writing to you and she is here now and says that I must tell you that she would much rather be with you than send you greetings’. The way in which Magdalena’s words are ventriloquised through the king demonstrates how closely her life was entwined with that of the royal family. Philip tacked on a commentary to this message that again reveals his concern for Magdalena’s failing health: ‘Although her feet lift whenever she hears music she gets so tired that she can’t dance. And the other day she had a fainting fit and remains weak.’ 

The princesses must have appreciated Magdalena’s humour as Philip passes on her quips, such as when she teases him for travelling on horseback like a child rather than taking a carriage. In fact, he says: ‘I feel so lonely in the carriage without you both and the days are so beautiful that it would be a shame to miss them.’ In the same letter, Philip complains that Magdalena – who had travelled ahead of him to Madrid – had not gone directly to visit his children as she had said she would, but ‘she never does what I tell her, and tell her that from me’. Despite this act of disobedience, the king nonetheless sends her affectionate greetings. Some time after Magdalena’s return to Madrid, Alonso Sánchez Coello painted her portrait kneeling beside Isabel Clara Eugenia. This is one of at least six portraits of her, though the majority are now lost.

This series of letters is invaluable for what it shows about the private/domestic and public/political spheres of Philip II’s life. Alongside local news and the activities of his companions, the king also tells his children about his daily routine in a way that is never patronising. They learn about the endless paperwork faced by a monarch, Philip’s long days and late suppers; his attendance at autos-da-fé where heretics were sentenced to be burned; his visits to galleons that plied their trade between Portugal and the New World; and his trips to religious institutions. But he is also frank about his frequent bouts of loneliness, allowing us to see the man inside the monarch. Together, these priceless nuggets of information can help us to achieve a richer and more rounded understanding of one of early modern Europe’s most powerful and fascinating figures.

Janet Ravenscroft is the author of ‘Invisible friends: questioning the representation of the court dwarf in Hapsburg Spain’ in Waltraud Ernst, ed., Histories of the Normal and the Abnormal: Social and Cultural Histories of Norms and Normativity (Routledge, 2006).