Madame: Elisabeth Charlotte of Orleans

The ungainly princess from the Palatinate was an unlikely bride for Louis XIV’s brother, writes Nis A. Petersen, but her frank nature and resourceful intelligence commended her to the King.

The news that set the French court talking in the late summer of 1671 was the impending marriage of Monsieur, younger and only brother of the King. Monsieur’s previous wife, Henrietta of England, daughter of Charles I, had died the previous year under mysterious circumstances and, as the King himself tactfully stated, a ‘vacancy’ now existed at court.

That this prized vacancy should be filled by the daughter of a minor German prince puzzled many. That the new consort of the elegant and effeminate Monsieur should be ungainly, unattractive and decidedly hoydenish was nothing short of astounding.

A combination of politics and feminine persuasion conspired to make Elisabeth Charlotte, Princess of the Palatinate and Duchess of Bavaria, one of the two legitimate heirs of the Elector Charles Louis, the second ranking lady at the French court. Though still impoverished, largely from the devastations wreaked upon it by the Thirty Years War, the Palatinate possessed for the French enormous strategic value. Louis XIV had started his policy of ‘frontier rectification’ aimed at extending French frontiers to the Rhine which would have meant annexing large parts of the Palatinate.

Should Elisabeth Charlotte be the sole surviving heir of her father, which seemed a good possibility since her listless brother might neither rule long nor produce offspring, then Louis could legitimately lay claim to much of the territory as part of her birthright or dowry, in the same manner as the King was laying claim to large parts of the Lowlands in the name of his Spanish-born Queen.

An equally important advantage that could accrue from the Palatinate marriage was the possibility of the electoral vote. The aspirations of the French monarchs to the imperial dignity dated back to Francis I. Should Monsieur become the Elector, Louis would be assured of one vote. Bribe money, lavishly distributed among the more impecunious remaining electors, might well produce the needed majority. tNo ambition seemed too far-fetched in those halcyon years.

What clinched the marriage was the tireless efforts of the Elector’s sister-in-law, Anne of Gonzaga, known at the French court as La Palatine. A born intriguer and through marriage part of that large, impoverished but gifted and eccentric brood of Elizabeth Stuart and Frederick V of Bohemia, she knew how to live by her wits and to press every advantage for her family.

Indeed, she had arranged for Monsieur’s marriage to the first Madame. Now she trained her battery of persuasion and diplomacy on the King, Monsieur, his favourites and the Elector. In August of 1671, she could write to him triumphantly, ‘Now sir, the marriage of your daughter with the Duke of Orleans is definitely settled, if you wish it. Monsieur wishes it and the King of France has given his full consent.’

The Elector was all too willing. His outspoken daughter, only recently returned from a long sojourn with his sister, the Electress Sophia of Hanover, mother of the future George I of England, was a constant source of irritation, largely because of her incessant criticism of her father’s morganatic and bigamous second marriage. Then, too, without a doubt this was a splendid match - the best in Europe. The Elector also fondly but, as he was eventually to discover, vainly hoped that his daughter would use her influence at Louis’s court to curb French designs on the Palatinate.

The most reluctant participants were the principals themselves. Monsieur’s aversion for all women was a well-established fact. Elisabeth Charlotte, or Liselotte as she was affectionately called by her countrymen, having witnessed from earliest childhood the cat-and-dog existence of her parents and the aversion of her Stuart grandmother for her own offspring, had no desire either to marry or to produce children. If she must marry, she hoped that it would be to a German prince. What overcame the resistance of both was their strong sense of duty.

Elisabeth Charlotte, perhaps more so than Monsieur, was prepared ‘to play the game’. The question of religion was quickly disposed of by her ‘secret’ conversion to the Catholic faith. The marriage contract was duly signed and on November 16th, 1671, at Metz, with the Comte du Plessis-Praslin serving as proxy, Elisabeth Charlotte of the Palatinate became officially the second Duchess of Orleans, henceforth to be known simply but regally as ‘Madame’.

Her entry into the glittering French court could not have been less auspicious. Upon seeing his new bride, garishly dressed in blue silk, her Ups stained purple from eating pomegranates, Monsieur wailed, ‘Am I supposed to sleep with that?’ Court gossips confidently predicted that the new Madame would not last so long as the first.

What they were to discover to their chagrin was that this Madame was made of sterner stuff than the former. Not only outspoken, but resourceful and highly intelligent, she was prepared to give her adversaries a good run for their money. What immeasurably eased her entry into this new world, and made her a formidable force in French court life for the next half century, was that the King from the outset liked her; she was to enjoy his affection and support until his death. She, in turn, indulged in a form of hero worship. Of all the personages the ‘Great Man’ alone could do no wrong. If he did, it was only because of bad advice.

What appealed to the King was Madame’s frank, outgoing nature, her broad tolerance, her utter lack of pretence and sham. She was like a breath of fresh air blowing through the hot-house atmosphere of his court. Louis was constantly amused and entertained by her raucous manner of speech, yet admired her propriety, her virtue and her brutal sincerity. They had many interests in common, including a love of dogs, horses, the hunt, walking and outdoor life in general.

Under the King’s tutelage, Madame became the most accomplished horse-woman in France. The attitude of the court soon changed from one of derision and contempt to that of wonderment and respect. Early in December, less than a month after the wedding, Madame de Sévigné wrote from far-off Brittany:

They say that the new Madame is not in the least embarrassed by the splendour of her position. They say that she has no use for doctors and still less for medicines... When they presented her with a doctor, she said she had nothing for him to do, that she had never been bled nor purged; that when she was not feeling quite fit, she took a six mile walk and that soon set her to rights.

Even Madame’s relations with her new husband fared better than expected. The two not only effected a modus vivendi, but even developed a grudging respect and affection one for the other. By the standards of the court, theirs was a fairly good marriage; and were it not for the influence of Monsieur’s two scheming favourites, the Chevalier de Lorraine and the Marquis d’Effiat, both of whom Madame instantly and cordially detested, it would perhaps have been an ideal marriage, given their diverse characters and tastes.

Madame dutifully bore her husband three children; and after this, they mutually agreed to live their separate lives: Monsieur to spend most of his time with his jewels, his clothes, his parties and his friends; Madame to the raising of her family which included Monsieur’s two daughters by his previous marriage, to reading, to collecting medals and engravings and above all to the writing of letters. Madame became one of the most prolific letter-writers of all time. As she grew older, she would spend ten to twelve hours a day at her desk writing letters often thirty pages in length.

With her innate good sense and candid self-appraisal, Madame knew that she could never really become part of her new environment. The full influence of the Enlightenment, which never really penetrated Versailles, was yet to be felt. Louis’s court lay under the heavy hand of Spanish etiquette which dictated that women should be submissive, decorative, and stupid. Madame was none of these. Brashly self-assertive, her stentorian tones could be heard from one end of the gilded salons to the other.

But what made her such a formidable figure was that she was always well-informed; she was probably the best-read person at court. Very much an odd-person out, she remained so to the end; a very square peg in a round hole. Yet it was this sense of detachment, this capacity to serve as a foil rather than as a mirror to her times, that give Madame’s observations their special flavour - that make them of interest to the casual reader and historian alike.

Madame’s overriding concern was for her family. In an age conspicuous for its lack of concern for the young, Madame’s maternal devotion stands out as her most admirable trait. It was for her children that she fought some of the bitterest battles of her life. Not only was she a good mother, but she had also definite ideas about the upbringing of children - a combination of love and discipline of which even a modern child psychologist would approve.

She reared her two step-daughters with the same care and devotion she lavished on her son and daughter. Her love and concern were reciprocated in kind. Her step-daughters and daughter corresponded with her until her death. Her son, later the Regent in the minority of Louis XV, visited his mother almost every day and insisted that every honour be accorded her.

Prevailing medical practices, in Madame’s opinion, posed threats to the welfare of children and adults alike. She mistrusted and even despised doctors, priests and lawyers, roughly in that order. She blamed the death of her first-born on the doctors, and felt that they had killed him as surely as they had dispatched so many of the Queen’s children and, finally, the Queen herself into the other world. As noted by Madame de Sévigné, Madame was highly dubious of the two most prevalent medical practices of her day, purging and blood-letting, and refused, until shortly before her death, to submit to either.

She tartly informed her doctors that her health and body belonged to her, and that she intended to manage them herself. Wholesome, preferably German food, fresh air and exercise were her medications. When she succumbed to smallpox, the memoirist Saint Simon noted with awe that she retired and cured herself ‘in her German manner’.

As if the malevolent ministrations of the medical profession were not enough to undermine a person’s health, Madame found prevalent eating practices and the food itself equally if not more pernicious. She never ceased to marvel and be alarmed at the vast quantities of food that members of the court, including Monsieur and the King, regularly packed away, often late at night, and darkly predicted that they would all ruin their digestions.

The preparation of the food equally distressed her. It seemingly resulted in little more than an endless succession of greasy meat pies and overcooked, over-spiced ragouts which nauseated her. The elaborate ceremony associated with the serving of the King’s meals meant that the food invariably arrived at the table stone cold. When the King dined au public or grand couvert with the immediate royal family - as was often the case - these disagreeable messes were consumed in dead silence in the presence of throngs of gaping spectators.

Madame was equally vocal in her detestation of the innovations of her time: chocolate, coffee, tea and tobacco. She loudly proclaimed that she would have nothing to do with any of them. She found chocolate to be too soft and sweet. Nothing could be worse for one’s health than coffee. In addition, it made the breath stink.

She compared the taste of tea to that of mouldy hay and rotten straw steeped in tepid water. As for tobacco, she particularly deplored the use of snuff by the court ladies. It infuriated her to see them walking about with dirty noses, ‘as if they had poked them in dung.’

At first lodged in the comfortable chateau of St Cloud and in the Palais Roy ale, Monsieur and Madame were assigned splendid apartments in the newly completed Palace of Versailles; and after 1682 this for the most part was to be Madame’s home until the King’s death. Knowing how sensitive the King was about his new house and its staggering cost, Madame diplomatically refrained from too much overt criticism; but there is indication enough in her correspondence that she was never really comfortable there.

The clipped trees afforded no shade; so Madame sweated in the summer. The flues, which could not be built high enough because they might destroy the famous roof-line, did not draw properly; so she froze in winter. The gravel on Le Notre’s vast parterres burnt through the shoes in summer and oozed black mud in winter. She agreed with Saint Simon that they were to be ‘admired, but avoided.’ ‘I prefer trees and grass,’ she wrote, ‘to the grandest palaces, and a kitchen garden to the most elaborate one with marble fountains.’

If the splendour of Versailles failed to impress Madame, the woeful standards of cleanliness did not. In fact, what she seems to have deplored most about France was the lack of cleanliness and personal hygiene she found everywhere, particularly in Paris. Madame may have been exaggerating (she often did for the purpose of emphasis), but in numerous letters she complains about the pervasive odour of urine, and the fact that she could not leave her apartments without seeing people urinating everywhere, often in the corridors.

Though both Monsieur and the King, in addition to herself, were immaculate about their persons, they seemed to be the exception. Madame describes in some detail the personal filthiness of the Princess d’Harcourt, one of the great ladies of the court. Her detestation of Madame de Montespan, the King’s former mistress, was heightened by that lady’s particular aversion to soap and water, and her attempts to mask this deficiency by the use of strong perfumes.

Madame considered the elaborate costumes, coiffeurs and use of cosmetics, which were the chief preoccupation of most of the great ladies of the court, to be nonsense and an utter waste of time. Strong scents gave her a headache; as did wigs and having her hair dressed. She much preferred her honest wrinkles to having rouge or other grease smeared on her face. As for jewels, she turned them over to Monsieur who could wear them to better advantage.

Her wardrobe consisted of three principal items: her grand habit, or state robe, which she wore to court functions, but which she had had designed with numerous tapes so she could slip in and out of it quickly; her riding habit, tailored like a man’s, but with a long trailing skirt; and her night shift. She augmented this meagre inventory with items specifically designed for comfort, such as a quilted dressing robe and otter-skin stockings to ward off the chills of the icy salons of Versailles in winter.

When she wound an old fur around her neck for additional warmth, she noted with amusement how it was copied by other ladies of the court. A fur tippet worn over the shoulders is known to this day as a ‘Palatine’.

A great many of Madame’s letters are devoted to discussing the morals of Louis’s court; and these form, perhaps, the most interesting part of her voluminous correspondence. So explicit is her language that for years unexpurgated editions of her letters circulated clandestinely, and even today some of the more salacious parts of her correspondence have to be toned down to make them acceptable to more squeamish readers.

Despite desultory efforts, Madame was never cured of her Billingsgate manner of speech. She believed in calling a spade a spade, and there was much she saw about her to be called just that. Not that she was shockable-she had seen and heard too much even as a child to be shocked - but she was disgusted. Early in life, she had formulated a strict code of ethics and moral behaviour from which she never deviated; and she felt that monarchs and members of the privileged orders would do well to emulate her example.

Yet she was realistic enough to know that her dream world was not to be, and tolerant enough to accept vices she found to be personally repugnant so long as they did not directly affect her or those near her. After all, as she charitably remarked, vices at her age were not contagious. From the beginning, she had to accept the fact that Monsieur was a homosexual; but she did not have to go far afield within her own family, or at court, to find others afflicted with what was termed the ‘Italian vice’.

Madame speculated on the sexual proclivities of both Queen Anne and William III. She found homosexuality rampant at court, especially in the army where, she felt, it was encouraged by Louvois the Minister of War. In fact, Madame sighed, if the King were really to punish all those guilty he would decimate all the great houses of France and would also have to close the College of Jesuits.

Gambling, drinking and conventional whoring distressed Madame as much. She particularly deplored the latter within the royal family because of the often embarrassing offspring it produced. She was prescient enough to foresee the complications that would ensue from Louis’s attempt to legitimatize his children by Montespan - those products of ‘double adultery’. That one of them, Mile de Blois, should be foisted upon her as a daughter-in-law was the greatest sorrow of Madame’s life. Mésalliances in general greatly disturbed her. She graphically termed them ‘mousedroppings among the pepper.’

Rather than seeking hedonistic diversions, Madame felt that kings and monarchs should exert themselves to do good, to administer justice fairly and rightly and spare their subjects the burdens of excessive taxation. It was to do this that God had placed them on their thrones.

Madame considered the exiled James II to be among the silliest of men, and caustically observed that, had he spent more time at his métier and less at prayer, he would not have lost three kingdoms. She was fully aware that, had it not been for her religion, she might have been the monarch to succeed Queen Anne. But she did not regret the succession going to her beloved Aunt Sophia. England may have presented difficulties. ‘I don’t think that there can be a country in the world,’ she observed, ‘where people revolt as often and as easily as England.’

Madame firmly believed that religion had no place in politics. In what was still in many respects a bigoted age, her religious tolerance is one of the most appealing aspects of her character. Virtually alone among the great persons at the French court, she deplored the persecution of the Huguenots that was to darken the closing years of the Sun King’s reign. ‘I must own,’ she wrote in exasperation, ‘that when I hear the Great Man praised in a sermon for his persecution of the reformed, I am always impatient. I cannot hear bad actions being praised.’

According to Madame, two factors were responsible for the King’s ‘bad actions’: he never read anything dealing with religion or religious subjects - both he and his brother hated to read. The second, and most important, was the effect exerted on him by the narrow piety of Madame de Main tenon, Madame reserves the choicest words in her extensive vocabulary for Louis’s last mistress and second wife. Not only did Madame hold her responsible for the deplorable persecutions, but also for the hated marriage of her son to Mile de Blois whom Madame de Maintenon had reared.

Early in her career, Madame had promised herself that she would take good care of herself, so she could have the satisfaction of burying her tormenters. Her efforts bore fruit. She did live to see them all in their graves; but unfortunately her friends and supporters departed first. She greatly lamented the death of Monsieur in 1701. The death of her beloved Aunt Sophia in 1714, and that of the King a year later, dealt a blow from which she never recovered. She became an old and broken lady, enjoying neither the privilege of being again the first lady of France nor the adulation of the Parisian populace.

Yet she faced death with the same good sense and courage with which she had faced the other problems of her life. This was, after all, ‘only the last absurdity we are capable of committing, so we put it off as long as possible.’ Informed that because of her health, she should not consider going to Reims to see Louis XV crowned, she retorted that she could go as easily to heaven from Reims as from Paris.

Against her better judgment, she permitted herself to be both bled and purged. On December 3rd, 1722, she wrote her half-sister that, if God would but give her two more days, she would answer her last letter. Such was not to be. She lapsed into a semi-coma and died on the night of December 8th, 1722. Shortly before the end, one of her weeping ladies sought to kiss her hand. ‘You may kiss me properly on the lips,’ Madame murmured. ‘I am going to the land where all are equal.’