On Friday 21 October 1966 a coal tip collapsed and slid down a mountainside onto the mining village of Aberfan in the South Wales valleys. It had been built on top of a spring, and there had long been local worries over its stability. The tip slide engulfed a farm, around 20 houses, and part of the local junior school. 144 people were killed; 116 of them were children.
For the parents and wider community of Aberfan, it was a horrific tragedy that left mental scars still present today. Beyond the village, the disaster carried different meanings; Aberfan illustrates how the memory and resonances of disasters can shift over time.
Register to read more articles for free.
When you register, you will receive the History Today newsletter. Click here to read our Terms of Use.
On Friday 21 October 1966 a coal tip collapsed and slid down a mountainside onto the mining village of Aberfan in the South Wales valleys. It had been built on top of a spring, and there had long been local worries over its stability. The tip slide engulfed a farm, around 20 houses, and part of the local junior school. 144 people were killed; 116 of them were children.
For the parents and wider community of Aberfan, it was a horrific tragedy that left mental scars still present today. Beyond the village, the disaster carried different meanings; Aberfan illustrates how the memory and resonances of disasters can shift over time.
The disaster immediately sparked worldwide sympathy. Television coverage showed the wreckage of the school, crowds of rescue workers searching for survivors, and anxious parents waiting for news. A disaster fund was set up by the mayor of nearby Merthyr Tydfil. It quickly raised £1,750,000. At least 50,000 donations were accompanied by letters from donors explaining why they were moved to contribute. Those from coal mining communities felt particularly touched by the tragedy, as did mothers who had lost children. People with Welsh relatives, or even just holiday memories, wrote of the warmth of the nation and its people; others that they could not imagine how it must feel to lose a child.
On 26 October the government ordered a Tribunal of Inquiry into the disaster. It emerged that the claim, by the National Coal Board’s (NCB) chairman, that the spring under the tip had not been known about was not true and that warnings had not been acted on. When the report was published on 3 August 1967 it did not hold back:
the Aberfan Disaster is a terrifying tale of bungling ineptitude by many men charged with tasks for which they were totally unfitted, of failure to heed clear warnings, and of total lack of direction from above.
The inquiry concluded that blame lay squarely with the NCB, with nine employees and the chairman of the board singled out for particular criticism. Yet nobody was prosecuted, dismissed, or demoted – or even said sorry.
Aberfan had to suffer other indignities, too: the NCB paid £500-a-head compensation to the bereaved parents. This was in line with legal precedents, but insultingly low. Coal board lawyers regarded it as ‘a generous settlement’.
In August 1968 the government forced the disaster fund to contribute £150,000 to the cost of removing the NCB’s remaining tips from above the village; the secretary of state for Wales, George Thomas, said that if the government paid, it would be ‘at the cost of some other Government project such as hospitals, housing, roads etc’. The tips were in a place and condition in which, according to the NCB’s own literature, they should never have been. They were also a daily visual reminder of the disaster, and the village worried about their safety. People wanted them gone, but the NCB said it could not afford the total cost.
People clear the wreckage of the Aberfan disaster, Jack Metzger, 22 October 1966. ETH Library Zurich, Image Archive / Com_L15-0703-0001-0005 (CC BY-SA 4.0).
Those who should have protected the community did not. The Charity Commission not only failed to stop the forced contribution to the removal of the tips, but instructed the disaster fund to ensure that parents were ‘close’ to their children before making any payments. The local council’s resources were overwhelmed, and it sometimes administered the financial, housing, and schooling needs of those affected with far less understanding than it should have. Pupils that had attended the destroyed school were sent to be educated at nearby Merthyr Vale. This school stood under a disused tip and had a clear view of the Aberfan cemetery where friends and relatives were buried.
This all created a strong sense of injustice and anger in the community. As one bereaved parent said: ‘I was tormented by the fact that the people I was seeking justice from were my people – a Labour Government, a Labour council, a Labour-nationalised Coal Board.’ This became its own news story, and local people grew deeply distrustful of media interest in their lives.
Within Wales there emerged a tacit belief that Aberfan was best left alone. In the 1970s and 1980s the wider memory of the disaster faded and, as the coal industry shed its last Welsh jobs, Aberfan increasingly seemed like an event from a distant past rather than from a recent decade more associated with pop music and sex than mining disasters. But at the end of the century British archival laws brought Aberfan new attention. In 1997, under the ‘thirty-year-rule’, government material on Aberfan was released. It showed how the community’s interests had been marginalised amid state wrangling over money and the possibility of job losses and strikes in the coal industry. When it came to compensation, legal precedents had been valued over common sense and humane justice. The needs and requests of the bereaved, undoubtedly suffering from PTSD, were seen as emotional and unreasonable. Regarding tip removal, a senior civil servant thought the village would expect a degree of consultation on technical matters ‘beyond what would be reasonable, and they may have to be spoken to firmly’.
The newly available archival material allowed historians to document the injustices inflicted on Aberfan. Knowledge of these scandals was then further disseminated by a variety of documentaries that drew on that research. Gradually, memory of the tragedy beyond Aberfan was revived and supplemented by a new anger at the failures that had followed it.
In Wales the disaster came to be seen as part of the nation’s history, taught in schools and marked each year by online public remembrance. With Welsh nationalism growing post-Brexit, the disaster was often pointed to as an example of the long history of mistreatment of Wales by the British government. In 2017 ‘Cofwich Aberfan’ (‘Remember Aberfan’) was graffitied onto the unofficial memorial, near Llanrhystud, to the flooding of the Tryweryn valley. This memorial occupies a significant place in the culture of Welsh nationalism and to many the addition seemed very apt.
The vivid depiction of the disaster in a 2019 episode of Netflix’s The Crown brought the tragedy to a new, global audience. There was a huge surge in the number of people searching online for Aberfan. Wikipedia daily page views went up after broadcast from an average 1,500 to 200,000.
The disaster still resonates. There remain considerable challenges to holding corporations accountable as commercial ventures, technological monopolies, and environmental harms cross borders and jurisdictions. In South Wales, at least two significant landslides have occurred at disused tips in the last decade. There were no casualties but they evoked memories, and fears, of 1966. The Welsh government, already struggling to deal with the legacies of deindustrialisation, has assumed responsibility for managing the remaining 2,589 coal tips. The UK government, which once owned the NCB, has made a £143 million contribution, but some say it should accept responsibility for all of the ongoing costs.
The Aberfan disaster was 60 years ago, but the issues that it raises, and the memories it invokes, are as poignant and urgent as ever.
Martin Johnes and Iain McLean are the authors of Aberfan: Government and Disasters (Welsh Academic Press, reissued 2019).