Mesmerism: Pain Management before Anaesthetics

Surgeons trying to eliminate pain eventually arrived at anaesthesia – but not before a contest with older, more unusual therapies. Why was mesmerism so magnetic?

A hypnotist using the ‘animal magnetism’ method, engraving after Daniel Dodd, 1802. Wellcome Collection. Public Domain.

Next time you reach for a bottle of painkillers, reflect on the agonies endured by surgical patients before anaesthetics were introduced in the 1840s. Waxing eloquent, Charles Dickens’ close friend Chauncy Townshend proclaimed: 

They who have heard, as I have heard, the dreadful shrieks, the sounds, more resembling the bellowing of a wild animal than the intonation of a human voice … They, and they alone, can appreciate the almost overpowering thankfulness which swells the heart in return for a gift that, in a few moments, causes the shrill cry to sink into a tremulous murmur.

Powerful rhetoric – but, far from extolling the virtues of ether and other chemical knockouts, Townshend was campaigning against them in favour of an older technique: mesmerism, or animal magnetism. He eventually lost the argument – but this was not a straightforward case of a quack gimmick being supplanted by a powerful drug. It was no foregone conclusion that ether would emerge the victor: medical politics and personal rivalries counted as much as scientific facts.

Cartoon of William Caxton's printing press: 'They get to read the first page for free, but if they don't register the rest appears in Latin'

Register to read more articles for free.

When you register, you will receive the History Today newsletter. Click here to read our Terms of Use.

Register

Already have an account? Sign in.