Thomas Edison, American inventor of the electric light bulb, once quipped that ‘Genius is one percent inspiration, ninety-nine percent perspiration’. However unglamorous it sounds, that hard-work approach is what drives scientific progress. Isaac Newton may or may not have had his own light-bulb moment in a country orchard, but he spent many years hammering out the mathematical calculations underpinning his theory of gravity. Methodical observation and analysis are what count, not sudden flashes of inspiration.
The chemical equivalent of Newton’s apple is August Kekulé’s snake. Dozing one evening in front of a fire, the German scientist dreamily imagined long chains of atoms gambolling through the air. Suddenly, he wrote, ‘one of the snakes had seized hold of its own tail, and the form whirled mockingly before my eyes’. This epiphany provided the vital clue he needed to address a problem that had been perplexing scientists for years: the molecular structure of benzene, a key chemical for the existence of life that was first identified by Michael Faraday in 1825.
When Kekulé woke up from his dream, he suddenly realised that benzene’s six carbon atoms are arranged not in a straight line, but in a closed loop. However, there was still a long way to go. Kekulé announced this breakthrough in 1866, but it was not until 1929 that his fleeting vision was converted into solid scientific reality. The details of his own theory failed to match laboratory observations and, as the petroleum industry expanded, deciphering benzene’s structure became the most pressing chemical question of the day. The true hero of this century-long quest was a young Irish crystallographer who proved that benzene’s six carbon atoms lie in a flat hexagonal ring. This discovery underpinned the study of carbon-based molecules, the basic building blocks of life.
Faraday’s molecular mystery was finally resolved by Kathleen Lonsdale (1903-71). She succeeded not through intuition, but by systematically analysing reams of mathematical data. Lonsdale took advantage of the latest X-ray equipment to probe right inside molecular structures, and – in the absence of computers – spent many months generating page after handwritten page of complicated calculations. By showing that the six carbon atoms in benzene are arranged in a flat symmetrical hexagon, she opened the door for unravelling more complex molecules.
Like so many female pioneers, Lonsdale has slipped from public awareness, but at the time she was internationally renowned. Ambitious, hard-working, and fiercely intelligent, she scored a string of firsts. As a student, she gained the top examination marks in the entire University of London, and she then went on to become the first female professor at University College London. She was still only in her early forties when in 1945 she won Britain’s top scientific accolade – Fellowship of the Royal Society, which until her arrival had been a resolutely men-only organisation.
Lonsdale continued to accumulate further distinctions, including eight honorary doctorates and a damehood. But despite all her achievements she was often portrayed as an abnormal woman rather than an exceptional scientist. In 1964, when Dorothy Hodgkin became the first – and still the only – British woman to win a Nobel Prize in science, the headline in the Daily Mail ran ‘Nobel Prize for British Wife’. Similarly, newspapers featured Lonsdale as a housewife and mother of three, as if her scientific research were merely a part-time hobby.
Meteoric rise
Nobody could have predicted such a stellar future for the youngest child of an Irish postal worker with an alcohol problem. Kathleen Lonsdale (née Yardley) was only five when her mother fled from her marriage and the uncertain political situation in Dublin to settle in Essex with her children. The family was so poor that some of Kathleen’s siblings were sent out to work, but she won scholarships. Determined to excel, she trained her memory by writing out the weekly sermon after church on Sunday.
Even as a teenager, she had decided that although she excelled at mathematics, it was the practical side of science that appealed to her. As she put it later: ‘You do the experiment – don’t fuss about what theory says.’ Nevertheless, it was so unusual for girls to study physics and chemistry that she had to attend classes in the local boys’ school. By the time she was 19 she had graduated in physics from the all-female Bedford College with the highest marks in ten years.
One of her examiners, Nobel Prize winner William Bragg, was quick to spot her potential and offered her a research position. Bragg has become renowned for supporting female scientists, but perhaps that was not entirely an altruistic gesture on his part: to have reached that level, a woman had to be exceptionally smart and determined – and as a further incentive for a team leader, women’s salaries were substantially lower than those of men at the same stage. But whatever his initial motives may have been, Bragg played an influential role in dispelling the widespread conviction that married women were incapable of pursuing scientific research. He remained Lonsdale’s patron until he died, even at one stage helping her to secure financial backing so that she could continue her research at home while her children were little.
For many professional women, marriage marked the end of their career, but Thomas Lonsdale – a textile chemist – insisted that his wife should keep working and ridiculed any notion that he was getting married in order to acquire a free housekeeper. The couple spent a brief period in Leeds – which is where she elucidated the structure of benzene – before returning to London, working mainly at the Royal Institution and University College. Progressing steadily up the career ladder, Lonsdale tackled a variety of problems – including artificial diamonds and bladder stones – and somehow managed to squeeze in a passion for table tennis, repurposing the balls to build complex molecular models.
Often asked how she coped with the multiple demands on her time, Lonsdale explained that for a female scientist it was most important to have ‘chosen the right husband’ and to learn how to concentrate ‘in any available moment’.
Science for peace
Lonsdale flouted several conventional expectations: not only was she married with three children, but she was also deeply religious, becoming a Quaker in her thirties after long soul-searching with her husband. Her faith underpinned every aspect of her life. ‘It is necessary to believe’, she wrote, ‘that in God’s world there is a right course of immediate action.’ Science and religion are often said to be incompatible, but she regarded them as intertwined: scientific research, Quakerism, and motherhood all depended on acquiring knowledge at first hand and maintaining a critical attitude to received wisdom. Quakers reject standard creeds, instead basing their faith on personal insights; similarly, she felt that children should gain from experience rather than learn by rote.
Like many Quakers, Lonsdale was a committed pacifist. During the First World War she did her homework hiding from bombs under a table. After watching a Zeppelin being shot down in flames, instead of rejoicing she was appalled at the suffering inflicted on her fellow human beings. When war broke out again in 1939 she refused to register for civil defence duties, preferring to consign herself to a month in Holloway prison rather than pay a small fine. The conditions inside were so atrocious that she became a lifelong campaigner for penal reform: she had not been prepared, she wrote, ‘for the general insanity of an administrative system’ that gave women no incentive to change their lives.
By the time of the Cold War Lonsdale was so eminent that she could exert pressure internationally. She served as the Vice President of the Atomic Scientists Association, which publicised the dangers of developing nuclear weapons, and she enjoyed a rapturous welcome in post-Hiroshima Japan in 1954. She also insisted that scientists in technologically advanced countries have a responsibility towards the rest of the world and should provide financial support for their schools.
Diamond in the rough
Kekulé’s snake is renowned, yet few have heard of the quiet unostentatious woman who finally resolved the benzene problem. While Kekulé lounged in an armchair and envisaged swirling snakes, she dreamt of, and worked towards, a better future, a world united in peace rather than one torn asunder by war.
In 1967, four years before Lonsdale died, mineralogists investigating a meteor site in Arizona identified a form of carbon that had never been seen before. They named it Lonsdaleite, because it has a hexagonal structure like the benzene molecules that she had decoded several decades earlier. Since then, experiments have shown that this hexagonal diamond is far, far harder than ordinary diamond. This seems a fitting tribute for a woman of apparently limitless energy who emerged from a disadvantaged background.
Patricia Fara is an Emeritus Fellow of Clare College, Cambridge. Alexander Lee will return next month.