Glasgow - A Moving Portrait
Allan Massie opens our special issue on Glasgow and urban history by reflecting on 'ways of seeing' the city's past and present.
The historian of a city is presented in an acute form with the question common to all historical writing: to what extent is history narrative? Or the question may be reversed: is it possible to stop the clock and paint a portrait which escapes being an illusion? There are some forms of history which lend themselves to linear treatment. Of course in any historical narrative different things are going on at the same moment, though they cannot be narrated simultaneously; nevertheless a battle, for instance, or a diplomatic negotiation, may be seen to have a beginning, a development, and a result. At the end of the day one army holds the field, and the other has withdrawn, or a treaty has been signed. No such conclusion is possible in urban history; it is always and forever in the making.
The temptation is to try to stop the clock. There is good precedent for the attempt. The historians of the influential French Annales school essayed what was essentially descriptive; history; the idea of movement was, if not eliminated, at any rate submerged. There was a genuine and worthwhile effort to arrest movement, to create a living portrait by the accumulation and deployment of significant detail. Yet it is impossible to read even the masterpieces of this school, like Braudel's volumes on The Mediterranean in the Age of Philip II, without feeling a lack. What has disappeared, or been stifled, is the concept of events taking place in time that never stands still.
When I came to write a book on Glasgow last year, I was conscious of the difficulties of treating urban history as narrative, and so subtitled it 'Portraits of a City'. Yet movement kept breaking in. I could not escape it, I could not avoid the knowledge that what the inhabitants of a city are principally conscious of is change. Where there were once fields, there are houses. Two-storey buildings are replaced by towering blocks. The consciousness of physical change is an experience no citizen can escape.
The first thing that changes in a city is its size. When Defoe at the time of the Treaty of Union, found Glasgow 'a large stately and well-built city, standing on a plain in a manner four-square, and the five principal streets are the fairest for breadth and the finest built I have ever seen in one city together', he was describing a place that no longer exists, that ceased to exist indeed within 100 years of the time of writing. What has that Glasgow but the name, the cathedral and the transplanted university in common with the city of today, or indeed with that of 1900 in which Charles Rennie Mackintosh lived and worked? Yet pride in the lost medieval city is strong. Consciousness that it was indeed there adds meaning to people's experience of the modern city. There is a considerable difference between living in a city with a past, and residing in a New Town. What is called the 'Heritage Industry' seeks out physical reminders of what used to be, and is even prepared to create simulacra of what time has destroyed, as Sir Arthur Evans did at Knossos.
It is possible indeed to suppose that really devoted heritage workers would be ready to build part of a city which was pure theatre. Yet the experience of visiting an extreme example of such devotion to heritage, like Williamsburg in Virginia, can only for anyone with a sense of history make the past seem unreal. History is movement, and when you freeze it, it dies. Glasgow offers a lively example, or would offer one; for the significance of Glasgow, since the Industrial Revolution created the Glasgow which we can recognise, is to be found in its restless appetite for change. Deny that, and you have altered what you thought you were preserving. Yet at the same time a deep-rooted nostalgia for pre-industrial Glasgow exists; Douglas Gifford has analysed the way in which 6lasgow novelists are drawn back to the idea of 'the dear green place', the undefiled ideal.
It is hard however to write either narrative or essentially descriptive history of a city without suspecting that you are guilty of falsification. Narrative history cannot fail to exclude from the story everything which seems irrelevant to its movement; yet, although people are conscious of physical change, they are also aware that the narrative of their own lives may not correspond to the chosen pattern. They suspect therefore that the story of a city is never accurate, because it omits much that should properly qualify it. But descriptive history is equally given to omissions and falsification. Its base is always too narrow. The historian may choose to rely on contemporary quotations to try to capture the life of a moment or a milieu. Such quotation is necessary to give life to the description, and certainly imparts a flavour which may indeed be characteristic. Here is an example taken from my own book. It comes from John Buchan's account of his youth in Glasgow, and he is describing his sensations on his morning walk from his home on the south side of the river to the University on Gilmorehill:
It was all a changing panorama of romance. There was the weather – fog like soup, drenching rains, winds that swirled down the cavernous streets, mornings that dawned bright and clear over snow. There was the sight of humanity going to work and the signs of awakening industry. There was the bridge with the river starred with strange lights, the lit shipping at the Broomielaw, and odours which even at their worst spoke of the sea. And at the end there were the gaunt walls of the college often seen in the glow of a West Highland sunrise...
I remarked that 'in this last sentence at least, Buchan caught something of the surprising magic of Glasgow: that it is a Highland or Celtic city, crouching incongruously on the edge of the Lowlands'. This observation is valid; yet it would he equally valid to represent nineteenth-century Glasgow as an outpost of the characteristically Lowland and Presbyterian values of thrift, industry, austerity and enterprise. Certainly these terms, all of which may accurately be applied to the Victorian city, are not such as many would naturally employ to describe Highland Scotland or Catholic Ireland, both of which supplied Glasgow with so great a part of its population.
Buchan's description is worth dwelling on a little longer. It is of course unashamedly subjective. It is certainly vivid; it reads like the programme for an Impressionist painting. It fits in with that wonderfully evocative phrase of the artist Muirhead Bone's: 'the engineering skies of Glasgow'. Yet, even while acknowledging this, one should question whether any of 'the humanity going to work' would have found the scene 'a changing panorama of Romance'? Buchan, one might suggest, is entranced by the idea of the city, and blithely ignores the realities of existence for those who made that idea possible by their labour.
There is, in urban history, a conflict between the social and the economic view. T.C. Smout emphasised this in the introduction to A Century of the Scottish People 1830-50:
To the economic historian [he wrote] there is a triumphal progression down to the First World War... Only the slump in the staple industries ushering in the interwar depression after 1920 brings this decisively to an end, and the Scottish economy, international leader in so many sectors up to that point, goes into a period of severe crisis that in recent decades has even been described as de-industrialization. To the social historian – or at least to me – things seem rather different. The age of great industrial triumphs was an age of appalling social deprivation...
Glasgow of course stands out as the exemplar, even the justification of this argument; no other city in Scotland could match its economic vitality or achieved comparable growth; nowhere else experienced social problems, common to the age though they were, to quite the same degree. The reconciliation of economic success and social failure is still the task that faces its historian.
This duality was evident within single industries. It was nowhere more dramatic than in the chemicals industry. For decades the factory chimney of the St Rollox Works – Tennant's Stalk – dominated the Glasgow skyline, and the greatest figure in the proprietorial family, Sir Charles Tennant, dominated the Glasgow business world and fed its imagination. His interests expanded from the bleaching process on which the family's wealth was founded, to pyrites, gold, iron and steel. His statue sits outside his tomb on Glasgow's Necropolis, the supreme and proud expression of capitalist achievement and self-sufficiency. When he died he left estate in the United Kingdom valued at three million pounds. It is possible to write the history of the city in terms of Tennant and other great industrialists as a story of quite astonishing success; and such history would not be a lie.
It would be less than the truth however. In 1879 the Tennant Works paid the average of their employees only 40 pounds a year; these people could hardly be said to have shared in their employer's glory. They did not even attain comfort. 'The chemicals industry,' Sydney Checkland wrote in the Dictionary of Scottish Business Biography, 'in spite of being science based, produced the nadir of working conditions, a scene of terrible male degradation.' The employees at one of Tennants' competitors, John R James White, were known either as 'White's Canaries', on account of the yellow dust that covered their clothes, or as 'White's Dead Men', because their faces were blanched by exposure to chemicals.
Moreover, the chemical factories spread the worst pollution. The atmosphere of their locality was poisoned with sulphurous fumes and deposits of alkali waste; greenish-yellow sulphurous liquid waste was discharged into streams, and eventually into the Clyde. Standing tanks of urine (the cheapest source of ammonia) harmed the health of those condemned to live in their vicinity.
Nor, however, did the paradox end there. These great polluting factories not only created wealth and destroyed the health of their workers; they contributed to a general improvement in living standards, even of hygiene. The production of cheap soap which Tennant's pioneered helped to eradicate diseases spread by personal filth.
The duality between an economic and social interpretation of history is equally apparent in the story of twentieth-century Glasgow. Only this time the situation is, as it were, reversed. Comparative economic failure expressed itself in high rates of unemployment, in the closure of factories, works and shipyards, and in a changed perception of the city; the market leader became a case for treatment, the driving-force of the Scottish – and indeed, among other cities, of the British – economy was now perceived as a drag on progress. The energy encouraged by consciousness of success was replaced by a lassitude born of a sense of failure. Self- confidence gave way to self-doubt. To account for this decline, Sydney Checkland elaborated the myth of the Upas tree, which:
...was believed to have the power to destroy other growths for a radius of fifteen miles... it is taken as a symbol of the heavy industry that so long dominated the economy and society of Glasgow... The Upas tree of heavy engineering killed anything that sought to grow under its branches... now the Upas tree, so long ailing, was decaying, its limbs falling away, one by one. Not only had it been inimical to other growths, it has, by an inversion of its condition before 1914, brought about limitation of its own performance.
The myth is seductive. Once heavy engineering has been equated with the malignant Upas tree, Glasgow's decline explains itself, even though Checkland himself is unable ever to account for its supposedly poisonous influence on other growths. The image indeed may supplant reality, excuse further investigation. A myth succeeds by its influence on the imagination, and the Upas tree is an unusually persuasive one.
Yet this period of relative economic decline was also a time of relative social progress. Whatever may he said against the quality of housing provided by the old Glasgow Corporation before and after the Second World War, it represented an improvement on what it supplanted. In every measurable way the condition of people of Glasgow improved:
The greatest advances in welfare have come since 1950, especially in the 1960s and early 1970s, when the standard of living and the environment were transformed for the better just as people were making the greatest moan about the decline of industry. [T.C. Smout]
Historians do not, of course, have to make judgements about success and failure, which can never, anyway, be other than relative, and also subjective, terms; we have no means of determining whether society is a success or failure, and it may be that the terms have no useful meaning in this context. Nevertheless, it is apparent that historians generally embody such assumptions in their work, just as the bias of commonsense observation of human activity is regularly given to judgement.
The difficulty this raises in the writing of urban history explains the attraction of myth, for myth is, among other things, a means of making sense of something which defies reason. One of the troubles with Glasgow history is that, though there are myths to hand, they are deficient myths because they have not found satisfactory artistic expression. Alasdair Gray hit on this truth in his novel Lanark:
Glasgow is a magnificent city. Why do we hardly ever notice that? Because nobody imagines living there... Think of Florence, Paris, London, New York. Nobody visiting them is a stranger because he's already visited them in paintings, novels, history books and films. But if a city hasn't been used by an artist not even the inhabitants live there imaginatively... Imaginatively Glasgow exists as a music-hall song and a few bad novels. That's all we've given to the world outside. It's all we've given to ourselves...
He overstated the case; there had been good novels and good paintings, there were great buildings. Nevertheless there was substance in his argument; Glasgow could scarcely be said to have lived fruitfully in the imagination of its citizens. Certainly the most conspicuous lack in the history of nineteenth-century Glasgow is the absence of any novelist able to do for the city what Balzac did for Paris, Dickens for London, Bely for St Petersburg, Musil for Vienna. By the same token it is reasonable to connect the city's recovery with the work of artists like Gray himself, Archie Hind, James Kelman and William McIlvanney, even though they may not be personally in sympathy with aspects of that recovery, or its nature, and their work even hostile to its manifestations.
It is the need of myth that accounts for the present importance of Charles Rennie Mackintosh to Glasgow. There is not, of course, a lot of Mackintosh's work in the city, and there are some, even among those who evoke his name, who do not necessarily greatly admire what there is. Nevertheless Mackintosh is the key figure in the city's cultural history, and significantly, he is one on whose importance historians of all schools can agree. He flourished, or was not permitted fully to flourish, at just the right time – around 1900 – when Glasgow's assurance was beginning to be undermined. The failure to make full use of his talents was perhaps the clearest sign of that loss of confidence in the city's own genius. Moreover, in his art, he sought to provide a bridge between the vernacular tradition and the modern movement. He was absolutely a man of 1900, as the advocates of the Viennese Jugendstil recognised, but he also sought to incorporate in Modernism the native values which he had inherited. For Glasgow today therefore, Mackintosh has become a sort of icon. Recognition of his genius combines a nostalgia, which may be called Jacobite, with an optimism that suggests that a synthesis of human and industrial values is possible. Mackintosh has become the lost leader who still points the way forward; he has become the satisfactory, and deeply satisfying, myth, which Glasgow can employ to inform its future. Most important of all, he is a unifying myth, one who can be used to make sense of the city's history and draw its different strands together. He shows, among other things, that it is possible to be both Celtic and modern. A Mackintosh building or design is self-sufficient and yet at the same time leads the eye and the imagination beyond itself: which is a good model for urban history.

