On 19 June 1867, Ferdinand Maximilian faced a firing squad in Mexico. At five in the morning, he heard mass and then had breakfast. Shortly afterwards, carriages arrived to take him and two other prisoners to the hill where they would be shot. There, dressed in black, with a buttoned frockcoat and carrying a crucifix, Maximilian made his final steps. With their backs to an uneven adobe wall, the three prisoners took their places. Turning towards his executioners, Maximilian said in Spanish: ‘I forgive everybody, I pray that everyone may also forgive me, and I wish that my blood, which is now to be shed, may be for the good of the country. Long live Mexico, long live independence.’
The firing squad was barely five paces away, but Maximilian beat his hands against his chest, indicating where the soldiers should aim. Then he glanced up. It was a cloudless day. The shots rang out. Maximilian fell to the ground.
Register to read more articles for free.
When you register, you will receive the History Today newsletter. Click here to read our Terms of Use.
On 19 June 1867, Ferdinand Maximilian faced a firing squad in Mexico. At five in the morning, he heard mass and then had breakfast. Shortly afterwards, carriages arrived to take him and two other prisoners to the hill where they would be shot. There, dressed in black, with a buttoned frockcoat and carrying a crucifix, Maximilian made his final steps. With their backs to an uneven adobe wall, the three prisoners took their places. Turning towards his executioners, Maximilian said in Spanish: ‘I forgive everybody, I pray that everyone may also forgive me, and I wish that my blood, which is now to be shed, may be for the good of the country. Long live Mexico, long live independence.’
The firing squad was barely five paces away, but Maximilian beat his hands against his chest, indicating where the soldiers should aim. Then he glanced up. It was a cloudless day. The shots rang out. Maximilian fell to the ground.
This death on a hill overlooking the provincial Mexican city of Querétaro was far removed from the splendour of Maximilian’s birthplace, the imperial palace of Schönbrunn, Vienna. He was a Habsburg archduke, but, as a younger brother of Franz Joseph, emperor of Austria, Maximilian was unlikely to have had a kingdom of his own in Europe. Convinced of his destiny to rule, Maximilian accepted an offer to become emperor of Mexico. Arriving in May 1864, he was shot barely three years later.
Sympathetic monarchy
The execution of an Austrian archduke was the catastrophic denouement of the foreign policy of the French emperor, Napoleon III. Although Maximilian had some support in Mexico, his rule was dependent on French military and financial power, which the French emperor deployed in 1862 to overthrow a republic led by President Benito Juárez and replace it with a French-sponsored monarchy.
The French emperor was able to embark on what today would be called ‘regime change’ because of a civil war in Mexico. Known as the Mexican War of Reform (1858 61), this was between two loose groups, liberals and conservatives. Liberals won and Juárez was elected president, but his government was bankrupt. In July 1861 Mexico’s congress, therefore, suspended international debt payments, most owed to Britain, some to Spain and France. Outraged, in October the three powers sent forces to occupy the country’s principal port, Veracruz, and to force the Mexican government into meeting its obligations.
For Napoleon III this was the pretext for a more ambitious plan: Mexico should be a monarchy. Unlike Spain’s other mainland possessions in the Americas, Mexico became independent as a kingdom, the short lived First Mexican Empire (1822-23). Now, a small group of exiled conservatives, desperate to return to power after defeat in civil war, argued for a Second Mexican Empire. The pitch to Napoleon III was straightforward: replacing a hostile republic with a sympathetic monarchy would safeguard European interests better than a one-off intervention to collect unpaid debts. Conveniently for the French emperor, another conflict, the American Civil War (1861-65), meant that Washington was powerless to oppose any European intervention. All that remained was the question of who would sit on this imagined throne.
Second son
For Napoleon III and his Mexican co-conspirators, Maximilian was the ideal candidate. He was a Catholic descendent of Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, who first brought Mexico into the Spanish empire. And, crucially, he was available. An ambitious second son, he was excluded from power, instead pursuing a naval career and acting as a diplomat for his brother Franz Joseph.
On a mission to Brussels Maximilian met Charlotte, daughter of Belgium’s king Leopold I. Charlotte, better known to Mexican history as Carlota, felt that she was no less destined for greatness than Maximilian. A precocious student who had read much but seen little, she was taken with the charming Habsburg archduke, marrying him in 1857. When a brief spell as governor of a Habsburg province came to an end in 1859, Maximilian was left without a meaningful position for what he – and Carlota – thought were his considerable talents. Instead, he lived as a dilettante, finishing work on a fairy-tale castle overlooking the Adriatic. Carlota saw their future as one of boredom, staring at the sea until old age. Thus, when Mexican monarchists offered a kingdom in October 1861, Maximilian was intoxicated with the idea. He did, however, place conditions on his acceptance, namely that he should be called to rule by the Mexican people.
Maximilian, Emperor of Mexico, and Charlotte, Empress of Mexico, c.1864. Museum of Arts and Crafts, Zagreb. Public Domain.
Yet the French experience in Mexico suggested Maximilian would not be as popular as Napoleon III and the conservative émigrés had promised. By January 1862 the three European powers occupied Veracruz, but the Spanish and British withdrew as it became clear the French were determined to overthrow Juárez and few Mexicans rallied to the monarchist cause. On 5 May 1862, the French attacked Mexico’s second city, Puebla, with 6,000 men. They were defeated after heroic resistance by the Mexican army. The day went down in history as Cinco de Mayo.
Undeterred, Napoleon III sent some 25,000 reinforcements and Puebla was finally taken in May 1863. With much of the Mexican army captured, Juárez could not hold the capital and retreated northwards. In June 1863 the French entered Mexico City and set up an assembly of handpicked monarchists, which, supposedly in the name of the people, called for Maximilian to rule as emperor.
Maximilian prevaricated for months, insisting that the assembly’s vote was insufficient proof as to the wishes of the people. Napoleon III and Mexican monarchists then bombarded him with various petitions from Mexico designed to convince him that the nation wanted him as emperor. But, as one French soldier charged with collecting these ‘votes’ admitted, the Mexicans ‘would have acclaimed the devil or the Grand Turk, if we had presented them as a candidate at the end of our sabres’. Nonetheless, spurred on by Carlota, Maximilian allowed himself to be persuaded. Napoleon III’s promises proved crucial. ‘You may be sure’, the French emperor assured Maximilian in writing, ‘that my support will not fail you.’
Viva el emperador?
On 10 April 1864 Maximilian accepted the crown. For almost three years the Mexican throne had been a pleasant reverie; now it was an overwhelming reality. After signing a military alliance with France, known as the Treaty of Miramar, Maximilian’s doctor found the new emperor had collapsed. Suffering from nervous exhaustion, he had fallen into a deep depression. Becoming an empress had the opposite effect on Carlota; she was energised, confident and took on Maximilian’s responsibilities while he convalesced. They were meant to leave the next day, but it was not until 14 April that a tearful Maximilian felt strong enough to depart for Mexico.
Franz Joseph and his brothers (Maximilian, third from left), c.1860. Library of Congress. Public Domain.
He was right to be worried. When his ship reached Veracruz on 28 May 1864 there were no crowds to greet him. Most people in Veracruz supported Juárez and the streets were deserted as Maximilian and Carlota were driven past unfinished arches intended to celebrate their arrival; strong winds the night before had blown down the scaffolding, which now lay on the ground. So chilling were her first impressions of Mexico that Carlota was nearly reduced to tears.
Maximilian and Carlota were welcomed more enthusiastically as they continued to Mexico City. Under a blue sky in the capital – one of the largest and grandest cities in the world – the streets were transformed by enormous arches made of flowers and mirrors adorned with Mexican and French tricolours. Thousands of Mexicans shouted ‘Viva el emperador! Viva la emperatriz!’ as the imperial couple made their way to the vast cathedral at the city’s centre, the reception banishing doubts that their arrival at Veracruz had raised.
The Mexican empire, however, was fragile. As Carlota wrote: ‘It remains an enormous experiment, for we have to struggle against the wilderness, distance, the roads, and the most utter chaos.’ Three problems compounded this chaos. First, Juárez remained undefeated. Second, the United States refused to recognise the empire. Third, the imperial treasury was perilously empty, yet the Treaty of Miramar bound Maximilian to maintain monthly payments to keep the French army in Mexico.
The liberal empire
Conventionally, the narrative of the Second Mexican Empire is that it was propped up by a few traitorous Mexican conservatives, reactionary bishops and French imperialism. Maximilian’s actions bely this simplistic interpretation. The conservatives who had offered him the throne expected their new emperor to overturn a series of liberal and secular reforms Juárez had implemented. Instead, reflecting his own moderate liberalism and also to win over Juaristas – Juárez’s supporters – Maximilian appointed liberals to his cabinet and largely adopted Juárez’s programme.
Far from trying to establish a reactionary regime modelled on a romanticised notion of the colonial past, Maximilian and his imperialista supporters wanted to create a new world by forging a national party between conservatives and liberals. Maximilian reformed Mexico’s education system, established an Academy of Arts and Sciences and improved conditions for labourers, providing such unheard-of things as lunch breaks, limited working hours and days off.
’Capture of Puebla by the French army under the orders of General Forey on May 17, 1863‘, by Victor Adam, 1863. Prints, Drawings and Watercolors from the Anne S.K. Brown Military Collection. Brown Digital Repository. Brown University Library. Public Domain.
For all his good intentions, Maximilian’s reforms revealed another major weakness of the empire: outside the capital and major towns imperial authority existed only on paper. Many of Maximilian’s reforms were simply never implemented. More practical than her husband, Carlota understood that, before decreeing ambitious laws, Juárez first had to be defeated. As one French general noted, she was ‘a woman of great sense, perfectly capable of directing matters’. Sadly, he lamented, ‘she does not wear the trousers ... in politics!’
Maximilian did win over a number of high-profile liberals to his cause, but Juárez’s resistance ensured that for many the empire would never be the legitimate government of Mexico. Unable to match the French and imperialista forces in open battle, Juárez retreated northwards, while his supporters waged a relentless guerrilla campaign.
The French response was brutal, making it harder for Maximilian to win hearts and minds. Many French soldiers were veterans of colonial campaigns in Algeria; the tactics used in North Africa were deployed in Mexico. Villages were burned down, captives tortured and suspected Juaristas executed. ‘If I were Mexican’, one French officer wrote, ‘what hatred I would have for these French, and how much I would make them suffer.’
Maximilian tried to overcome the contradiction between Mexican nationalism and European dynastic rule propped up by foreign troops. He adopted local dress, put on elaborate independence day celebrations and made patriotic speeches, claiming ‘every drop of my blood is now Mexican’; however, many remained unconvinced. After one such speech, which French soldiers attended in uniform, Maximilian wrote, ‘the enthusiasm was indescribable’. For others, though, it was describable: ‘I assure you’, wrote a witness, ‘that never have we seen one of these occasions in which there has been so little enthusiasm.’ It was a ‘ridiculous and shocking spectacle [to see] a foreign army celebrating the anniversary of independence’.
Unsustainable endeavours
The second problem that the empire faced was US opposition. During the American Civil War, Washington refused to recognise Maximilian’s government, but remained neutral for fear of provoking French interference on behalf of the Confederacy. When the South surrendered in April 1865, bellicose civil war heroes – notably Ulysses S. Grant – urged military intervention to end what they saw as a plot against America. The French emperor had publicly stated that intervention in Mexico was designed to restore ‘the Latin race’ after Mexico’s defeat in the Mexican-American War. Indeed, the term ‘Latin America’ was coined in Paris in the 1850s, but, with a military larger than at any other time in its history, far from checking the rise of the United States, Napoleon III was merely afforded the opportunity to witness its power first hand.
’The Last Moments of Maximilian’, print after Jean Paul Laurens, 1884. Metropolitan Museum of Art. Public Domain.
Fear of US reprisals prevented the French from capturing Benito Juárez. The Mexican president had made his capital in the northern border state of Chihuahua. In August 1865 French forces entered the state capital, forcing Juárez and a few hundred followers to flee to Paso del Norte (today Ciudad Juárez) on the US border. Although only a few days’ march away, Napoleon III feared a border incident might provoke war with the United States and his troops had instructions to go no further. Crucially, increased confidence in the republican cause now meant Juaristas could raise loans from US subscribers.
Meanwhile, the empire was facing bankruptcy. Maximilian’s profligacy did not help. Applying a thick veneer of pomp to set up an elaborate court, he and Carlota were allotted $1.5 million a year from the state; as president, Juárez’s annual salary had been $30,000. Maximilian chose furniture, delicate china and beautiful crystal for his various residences, which were shipped from Europe and carried in mule trains to the capital at great expense. At lavish dinners and balls, oysters, quail and truffles were washed down with the finest champagnes – one advantage of heading a French-backed regime. The palace’s food and drink budget for 1865 alone was $104,821. It was, however, the Treaty of Miramar and European loans that burdened Maximilian’s government with unsustainable debt. Soon repayments accounted for four fifths of the empire’s revenue; government officials and soldiers went unpaid.
By December 1865, Maximilian had to ask Napoleon III to cover payments to France. Instead, Napoleon III announced in January 1866 that Maximilian’s government ‘founded by the will of the people’ was consolidated; ‘dissidents vanquished’. This was for public consumption. Napoleon III knew that the only way to save Maximilian would be to commit more men and money, but the French emperor wanted empire on the cheap. He had envisaged a few thousand French soldiers supporting imperialista collaborating elites – all the benefits of colonialism to France at a fraction of the cost. He did not want another Algeria, which tied down some 100,000 French troops. Besides, the United States now made clear that, if any French soldiers remained in Mexico, then it would be war. Napoleon III, therefore, decided on a phased withdrawal, with his last troops leaving at the end of 1867.
Abdication crisis
When Maximilian learned of this, he resolved to abdicate. Carlota was furious. Admonishing him for cowardice, she told him that medieval kings at least waited until ‘someone came to take their states away from them’. She persuaded her husband to stay while she went to Paris to change Napoleon III’s mind.
She failed. Despite presenting the French emperor with the letter in which he had written to Maximilian ‘you may be sure that my support will not fail you’, Napoleon III was unmoved. Perhaps not unmoved – Carlota reported to Maximilian that the French emperor cried during their meetings – but the decision stood. The failure proved too much, her mental state deteriorated. She perceived the French emperor’s betrayal in biblical terms, writing to Maximilian that Napoleon III was the ‘principle of evil upon earth’ and the ‘devil in person’.
Portraits of Emperor Maximilian of Mexico, Tomás Mejía, and Miguel Miramón and firing squad, superimposed on photograph of their place of execution, at Querétaro, c.1867. Library of Congress. Public Domain.
Carlota then journeyed to Rome for discussions with the Pope. She suffered a nervous breakdown in the Vatican. Sobbing before the Pope, she claimed that Napoleon III was trying to poison her, that his spies were everywhere and that her entourage was in his pay. Eventually she agreed to leave the Papal palace, sequestering herself in her hotel rooms. Here she insisted a servant obtain a small stove, a basket of eggs and two live chickens, which had to be killed, prepared and cooked in front of her, so paranoid was she about poison. Too ill to return to Mexico, she never fully recovered and was taken into care by her Belgian family, where she remained, moments of lucidity punctuating her delusions, until she died in 1927 .
Oblivious to his wife’s condition, Maximilian abandoned his principles to cling to power. With Juárez resurgent, Maximilian realised his moderate liberalism held little sway over the country, but his policies had alienated the conservative party. Indeed, so worried was Maximilian that he had disbanded much of the imperialista army, whose loyalties he feared were not to him, but to their conservative generals. Suddenly without income, these soldiers swelled the ranks of Juarista guerrilla forces. In September 1866, therefore, Maximilian announced a volte-face; to rally Catholic Mexico behind the empire, he sacked liberals, appointed conservatives and then waited for news from Europe.
It came in October 1866. Maximilian learned not only that Napoleon III would send no more men or money, but also that the French emperor wanted his troops to leave by March 1867, earlier than planned. It was news, however, of his wife’s condition that broke Maximilian. Carlota had encouraged him to go to Mexico, assisted him in its government and convinced him to stay. Now, alone except for a few courtiers, prone to debilitating bouts of depression and fever, he decided to abdicate. Maximilian left Mexico City to be nearer Veracruz and his possessions were shipped to Europe.
After 40 days Maximilian was talked out of leaving by his conservative allies. He delegated this decision to his advisers and cabinet, who voted on the empire’s future. Instead of listening to their deliberations, Maximilian went butterfly hunting. When he returned, he discovered that they had narrowly voted for the empire to continue.
In January 1867 he finally returned to his capital to take up again the reins of government, or what was left of it. With the French leaving, Maximilian vacillating and the salaries of soldiers and officials long unpaid, what support there had been for the empire beyond the conservative party melted away. At this point, Maximilian controlled only Mexico City, a few towns to the north-west and a ribbon of strongholds that ran eastwards to Veracruz – the French escape route. The commander of the departing French forces warned Maximilian that, if he stayed, it would be as the head of a faction fighting a civil war that would almost certainly be lost, but Maximilian’s remaining supporters were determined to have this war.
At dawn on 5 February 1867 the French flag was lowered from its headquarters in Mexico City. Crowds lined the streets, staring silently as the French troops marched out of the capital. Behind the soldiers came imperialista refugees, following in the safety of the French army’s wake. So outraged was Maximilian at what he saw as France’s betrayal that the windows and doors of his palace were pointedly shut. On the roof, the emperor, wrapped in a grey cloak against the morning chill, peered out from behind a parapet. Once the last French soldier was out of sight, he reportedly turned and said, ‘At last we are free!’
Emperor Maximilian's coat with bullet holes, resting on valet, c.1867. Library of Congress. Public Domain.
Maximilian used this freedom to lead what remained of the imperialista army. On the morning of 13 February he rode out from Mexico City at the head of only 1,500 men (and with just $50,000) to defend what was left of his empire. One of his flagship policies had been ending forced conscription, but now this, too, was abandoned. Pressed into service less than six weeks before, many of the troops still wore the ragged clothes in which they had been seized. As for Maximilian, he had never served in an army, let alone commanded one.
The plan was to reinforce beleaguered imperialistas at the city of Querétaro, 130 miles north-west of the capital. His conservative generals claimed that, if the emperor won a victory here, confidence in his rule would be restored. Maximilian and his makeshift force were soon under attack from guerrillas, but made it to Querétaro, where the imperialistas now had some 9,000 soldiers; the rapidly advancing liberals had at least 30,000. At the beginning of March, the city was under siege.
Maximilian and his small army resisted. Hunger and desertions forced a failed attempt to break out through Juarista lines on 27 April. A second desperate push was planned for mid-May. Before it could be launched, Miguel López, who had been part of the escort that welcomed Maximilian to Mexico in 1864, crossed into enemy lines and betrayed the emperor. In the early hours of 15 May, he led republican forces through a weak spot in the city’s defences. After briefly trying to rally his troops, Maximilian surrendered.
The former emperor was then court martialled. The trial was little more than political theatre, conducted in an actual theatre named after the first emperor of Mexico, Agustín de Iturbide, who had been executed in 1824. It took two days to hear the evidence and deliver the sentence. Despite the protests of the courts of Europe, the United States and republicans such as Giuseppe Garibaldi and Victor Hugo, Juárez would not relent. Maximilian was executed on 19 June 1867, alongside two conservative generals. Their deaths marked the end of nearly ten years of fighting between liberals and conservatives, a conflict which Maximilian little understood, but did much to prolong.
The failure of imperialism
The execution of Maximilian marked the failure of French imperialism in Mexico. Central to any explanation for this is Benito Juárez. His bravery, courage and unswerving belief in republicanism and liberalism saw him triumph. His resistance prevented the quick, cheap victory Napoleon III expected, until pressure from the United States forced the French emperor to abandon Maximilian. Without the French, the Second Mexican Empire rapidly collapsed in the face of a resurgent and popular nationalist movement.
Maximilian’s profligacy, his prevarication and his hubris in accepting the throne all played their part in his downfall. Still, it was not entirely his fault. In Édouard Manet’s painting, The Execution of Emperor Maximilian, there are many inaccuracies. Maximilian was not in the centre, nor did he wear a sombrero. But the painting does contain a message that Maximilian would have welcomed. The soldiers in the painting wear uniforms similar to French troops and the man on the right, preparing for the coup de grâce, shares the conspicuous features of Napoleon III. The implication was clear: the French emperor had blood on his hands.
Edward Shawcross is the author of The Last Emperor of Mexico: A Disaster in the New World (Faber & Faber, 2022).