Egypt under the Ptolemies

For nearly three hundred years, a Macedonian-Greek dynasty, who proved themselves to be able and adaptable rulers, held sway over the ancient Egyptian kingdom. By E. Badian

Alexander the great had built up an empire stretching from the borders of Illyria to the Punjab and from the northern edge of the Iranian plateau to the borders of Ethiopia. So firmly had he established his control over this vast area that even his unexpected death in June 3231 did not lead to any revolts, except among his Greek subjects.

But although his name continued to keep the conquered races in subjection long after his death, he left no heir to hold his empire together. Fear and suspicion had caused him to exterminate nearly all his male relatives, and at his death only an imbecile son of his father Philip II was left. The Macedonian army assembled at Babylon, probably not fully aware of his condition, insisted on electing him King, and he duly became Philip III.

Not long afterwards, Alexander’s Iranian wife bore him a posthumous son, who, as Alexander IV, was associated with Philip in the kingship. Needless to say, this did nothing to strengthen the monarchy, which never recovered its authority.

Alexander’s great generals, with the exception of one or two who were soon eliminated, had no genuine interest in preserving the unity of the Empire; each of them thought only of seizing the largest possible part of it for himself, and their struggles kept it in a state of chaos. For a time at least the fiction of a unified Empire was kept up: the rival commanders, many of them addressed as “kings” by their subjects, officially still called themselves governors or generals and protested their loyalty to one or both of the Kings.

But before long, inevitably, the Kings were killed. All pretence could now be abandoned, and by 304 the greatest of the Successors were openly using the royal style. Fighting among them continued for another generation, until sheer exhaustion produced a relatively stable political map. By the second quarter of the third century three kingdoms controlled the greater part of what had been Alexander’s Empire: the line of Antigonus ruled Macedonia and part of Greece, that of Seleucus most of the Asiatic provinces, while that of Ptolemy the son of Lagus, based on Egypt, controlled the Aegean and as much as it could of its islands and coastline.

The political history of these dynasties is, on the whole, one of constant tension, frequently flaring up into external and civil wars, and of a steady decline in power and prosperity, until the Roman Empire gradually engulfed them all. The Antigonid Philip V, by allying himself with Hannibal when the latter seemed about to secure final victory over Rome, first turned Roman power and attention towards the Eastern Mediterranean, with disastrous results for himself and his successor Perseus: in 167 the dynasty suffered final defeat.

The Seleucid Antiochus III, after temporarily restoring the fortunes of his house, became involved in a war with Rome and was decisively defeated in 190. Although the dynasty lasted for more than another century, it was as a troubled vassal of a suspicious Roman Republic, until Pompey gave it the coup de grâce in the sixties of the first century. The Ptolemies avoided seriously offending Rome; as a result, although fatally weakened before either of their rival houses, they outlasted both of them, holding Egypt, by the grace of Rome, until the death of the great Cleopatra in 30.

After Alexander’s death, Ptolemy, by no means the most important of his generals, had been assigned Egypt, a province well away from the centres of the Empire. At the time it was in the hands of another governor, and Ptolemy had to deal with him first. Then, recognizing the peculiar possibilities and limitations of Egypt, he brilliantly adapted his policy to them. Egypt, in antiquity, was a vast natural fortress.

Conquered by the Persians in the sixth century, it had regained its independence in the fifth, and, under its last three native dynasties, defended it for sixty years, until a decade before Alexander’s conquest. Protected by sea and desert, amply supplied with labour and food—Herodotus had called it “the gift of the Nile,” and the fertile and densely populated river valley was one of the granaries of the ancient world—the country had, however, lacked native military skill, and rigid tradition had stifled progress in all spheres. The Persians had been defeated by Greek mercenary commanders and soldiers, with the help of Greek organizers and administrators; and the Persians had regained Egypt, when these Greeks were induced to change sides.

Ptolemy, from the very first, showed that he had learnt the lesson. He used the wealth of the country to recruit military forces abroad, to make Egypt impregnable by building a strong navy, and to engage in constant diplomatic activity abroad. He soon gained a great advantage by seizing Alexander’s body on its way to Macedonia and building a mausoleum for it in his capital Alexandria, the greatest of the cities Alexander had founded. He used every weakness among his enemies, or even his allies, in order to extend his power.

But he carefully refrained from the risk of major military activity abroad. His successor—also called Ptolemy, like all male rulers of the dynasty—was controlled by ambitious advisers, who at one time extended Egyptian influence over most of the Aegean. When he died in 246, Egypt seemed set on the path to hegemony over the Hellenistic world. But he had overstrained his resources, and the third Ptolemy at first continued this policy. Before long he was forced to give up most of his conquests, and the dynasty never fully recovered.

By the time of Ptolemy IV’s death in 205, Egyptian power had collapsed, and it was only the Romans who, for reasons of their own, henceforth protected the dynasty, while keeping it weak and divided: racked by civil wars and palace intrigues, it survived in a steadily shrinking territory, until it became fatally involved in Rome’s civil dissensions.

While the fortunes of the other dynasties are by no means devoid of interest (as I have at times tried to show in this journal), Ptolemaic Egypt has a peculiar fascination for the historian. The evidence for most periods of ancient history is very different from that on which the modern historian chiefly relies. There are normally neither state archives nor the private documents of great men, neither newspapers nor the records of ordinary citizens. At the best, evidence is collected from literature—of which only the merest fragments survive—and this is supplemented by archaeological finds.

For many periods the latter, fortunately, include a large number of contemporary inscriptions on imperishable materials (chiefly stone), and owing to the Greek and Roman liking for imperishable records, these inscriptions to some extent take the place of public and private archives. Yet, quite apart from the chance of survival and discovery, the picture they present is far from adequate. It was only documents considered of some importance that would be engraved, and the result of this can be considerable distortion.

Thus, if we go by their inscriptions, the guilds of the Roman Empire existed chiefly for social purposes and had no serious functions and interests. Yet, though we know very little about them, we can see that they did have important civic and economic functions, the details of which largely elude us owing to the lack of evidence on their humdrum day-to-day working. In the case of Egypt, however, the usual sources are supplemented by papyri.

Egypt, in antiquity, was fortunate in being the home of the papyrus plant. This aquatic plant, which flourished in the marshes of the Lower Nile, provided the ancient world with one of its favourite writing materials—and, indeed, it has left its name to that of our own world. The pith of the plant was cut into strips, which were glued together with its own sap in two layers placed at right angles to each other. Sheets of this “paper,” after some treatment, were glued together to form rolls, which, with their columns of writing on the inside, looked rather like scrolls of the Jewish Law, or, when unrolled, not unlike a printer’s proofs before folding and cutting.

Papyrus was fairly cheap in Egypt, and it was used economically to make it cheaper still: when the contents of the right side were no longer needed, the wrong side could be used for less formal writing. The hot and dry sands of parts of Egypt—and hardly any other part of the ancient world—have preserved large numbers of such papyri. They have been found in ruins and rubbish heaps, and we have reason to be thankful for Egyptian religious customs, which led to their being frequently made into mummy cases or used to wrap and stuff sacred crocodiles after death.

Tens of thousands have thus been discovered in the last sixty-odd years, and many are covered with writing on both sides. Most of them are in Greek, though various forms of Egyptian and other languages are represented.

Our knowledge of Greek literature has been revolutionised by these finds, publication of which is far from complete. The recent discovery of a complete play—the Dyskolos (Misanthrope) of Menander—will be fresh in the minds of many listeners to its B.B.C. production. More important for the historian is the fact that, in the last two generations, a small part of the ancient world has really come to life for us. Here is a true random sample of the written matter that accumulated in an Egyptian town or village: from copies of royal proclamations and ordinances to schoolboy exercises, tax receipts, and the letter of a wife to an absconding husband.

The papyri have their limitations: most of them are damaged and fragmentary; they are found only in a few parts of Egypt (notably the Fayum), where soil and climate have preserved them; and they are by no means evenly distributed over the enormous time-span they cover. (Thus, for no very clear reason, the third century is much better represented than the second and first.) We are forced to generalize from them, but must recognize that these generalizations may be quite wrong. Nevertheless, and in spite of the fact that the masses of unimportant household documents become tedious and unprofitable after one’s first excitement, it is not surprising that “papyrology” has attracted some of the most brilliant scholars in the field of ancient studies, with results of outstanding importance far beyond the history of Greek and Roman Egypt. But it is this history that they chiefly illuminate.

The Pharaohs, sons of the Sun God and gods in their own right, had always ruled autocratically, though the power of the priests had provided a balancing force: the strength of a king could be gauged by the extent of his control over the temples. At the bottom of the social ladder, the fellahin had always worked hard for a bare living. This general situation was not changed by the coming of the Macedonians. Ptolemy I, like Alexander before him, seems to have respected Egyptian institutions and to have been duly crowned Pharaoh: in Egyptian theory, he might be said merely to have founded the thirty-second dynasty.

It is doubtful whether the fellahin—the vast majority of the population—noticed any real change for a long time. If they had to pay heavy taxes and were liable to forced labour, this was nothing new. In particular, the period of Egyptian independence in the fourth century had been bought at the cost of constant economic strain. When the Demotic Chronicle charges the last of the native Pharaohs with forgetting the gods in his thirst for riches, the charge—demonstrably untrue—clearly shows that the priests were made to bear part of his economic burden. Greek sources make it clear that general taxation was also tightened up during this period.

The Persian conquerors, who adopted a policy of severe repression, will hardly have reduced it; and Alexander’s financial superintendent made a name for himself by extortion unusual even in Egypt. In the circumstances, the Ptolemies’ fiscal policy was not felt to be oppressive. We know, for instance, that they did not continue the profitable corn monopoly established by Alexander’s superintendent.

We do not, however, know many details of Ptolemy I’s administration. The first Greek papyri of any importance date from the reign of his successor. The most interesting of them are the “Revenue Laws,” dealing with the organization of royal control over the economy, and the bulky archives of the Carian Greek Zeno, the trusted agent of Apollonius, who for at least fifteen years was Chancellor of the Exchequer to Ptolemy II and thus probably responsible for a great deal of the organization that was to remain basically unchanged for centuries.

After administering other business for his employer, Zeno finally settled down to run the huge estate that Apollonius had received from his royal master in the Fayum. We are fortunate in having these files, for there is hardly an aspect of public or private life not represented in them. With the help of these and other documents, we can build up a picture of the Egypt that was taking shape during those years.

The new kings were faced with two principal economic problems. First, they had to increase the productivity of the country, so that it would provide for the large number of foreigners—Macedonians, Greeks and Asiatics—whom the new rulers were attracting into the country, and many of whom, although highly useful as soldiers, administrators, traders and financiers, did not engage in the labour of basic production. These men had to be supported without serious inroads into the surplus of primary produce (chiefly corn) traditionally exported in exchange for Egyptian imports.

Next, the kings not only had to take their share of the wealth of the country, but to take it in such a way that proper budgeting became possible; and they had to take much of it in cash, in an economy based on barter: for the immigrants were accustomed to cash economies—the Egyptians, who had had no currency before Alexander, never came to feel really at home with it—and Ptolemaic diplomacy constantly required large sums of ready cash.

Productivity, in Egypt, depended almost entirely on the Nile: a rise or fall of a few cubits in the level of the inundation could mean the difference between abundance and starvation. The new kings embarked on ambitious projects of irrigation, supervised by Greek engineers. Two such men, Cleon and Theodoras, were chiefly responsible for restoring and greatly increasing the fertility of the Fayum district, about which our information is best.

Not only was the fertile area thus extended, but much marginal land was brought into production by the planting of vineyards, olive-groves and various fruit-trees that will flourish where corn will not, and that the Egyptians had hardly known hitherto. The primitive system of Egyptian agriculture was improved by the introduction of new species and by experiments with new strains, imported from all over the Aegean world, as well as by more skilled methods of farming.

As a result, two and sometimes three crops could be obtained in many areas. That the natives did not always approve of the “planners,” and that difficulties of a kind not unfamiliar today sometimes arose, is shown by one of the Zeno papyri, in which peasants complain of “lots of blunders,” said to be due to the fact that “there is no one here who knows anything about farming.”

The King not only pursued this progressive policy on his own land, tilled for him by his “royal peasants,” but encouraged others to do the same. In theory all agricultural land was the King’s. In practice, large tracts of it were assigned to the temples or (as “gifts,” but only leasehold) to the King’s friends, or distributed as allotments to soldiers. These practices were traditional in Egypt, though the Ptolemies greatly extended the system of soldiers’ allotments. The early Ptolemies, however, kept this assigned land fairly well under control.

But with the decline of the dynasty, both the amount of such land and the independence of the holders increased, until large and ever increasing areas were in fact private property. This, although it lost the King some revenue, did not necessarily mean less efficient fanning. Under Ptolemy II, we see Apollonius and his agent Zeno devoting constant care to the improvement of the vast estate, which the Minister held as a “gift” in the Fayum—both for the sake of their own profits and, as is at times explicitly stated, to please the King.

As more and more land escapes the King’s control, we find allotments including more unimproved land, and the cultivation of fallow or marginal land becomes a condition of many leases granted by the King: they are granted for rather longer terms in order to guarantee the lessee a reasonable profit from his investment. Although the troubles of the last period of the dynasty naturally led to some decline in farming, the Ptolemies can fairly be credited with a considerable improvement in the productivity of Egypt.

The King meant to have as large a share as he could of the wealth of the country he had conquered. Apart from the stereotyped verbiage of public monuments—the best-known of them the Rosetta stone—there was little high-sounding pretence or even self-deception about the Ptolemaic monarchy. Instructions to officials do not stress the welfare of the subjects, but freely refer to increasing the King’s revenue. This was the principal standard applied: even convicted prisoners were given a temporary release when the time came to work the King’s land—needless to say, not for humanitarian reasons.

In a similar spirit, the Chancellor advises his subordinates (in what appears to be a standard circular) that, if they carefully follow his instructions, they will be assured of personal safety and promotion. Conversely, at every stage of the collecting process that was their principal raison d’être, every official is liable with his person and property for any breach of instructions or loss to the King. Naturally, officials must therefore be given extensive jurisdiction, and there was practically no private business in which they did not intervene; for the King derived considerable profit—in the form of rents, rates, dues and taxes, tariffs, or at least licence fees—from almost every single transaction in Egypt.

Although the details are much discussed by scholars, the general picture is clear: not until quite recent times has there ever again been a society so efficiently organized for the maximum profit of the State—and the State, as we have seen, was the King. Some key commodities were kept entirely under royal control. The best-known of them is oil (except for olive oil, not commonly used by Egyptians): we happen to have the ordinance regulating the monopoly. From the sowing of the State-owned seed, through the crushing in Government mortars at prescribed speeds and fixed wages, to the retail sale nominally in private hands, but in fact at State-controlled prices, the whole process is kept under a constant supervision that even modem governments might envy.

At every stage it is hedged about with royal seals and fantastic penalties, and only the temples are grudgingly given a carefully supervised freedom to supply their own needs. No one could escape the King’s exactions: it is instructive to find the great Apollonius paying his taxes like any peasant, and to see detailed lists of articles he imported for business and pleasure, with the high duty he was charged on them.

Yet the King wanted not only a large yield, but a calculable one, and one that would give him a large cash surplus. The chief instrument for achieving this was the farming of taxes, introduced by the Ptolemies into a country that had never known it. Unlike the Roman Republic, they had an administrative machine perfectly capable of collecting the taxes. In fact, it always did so, and the tax-farmer was, administratively, an awkward excrescence. But it was he who relieved the Government of any risk and enabled the King to budget for his revenue; for he, with his person and property, which had to be considerable, guaranteed the yield of the tax.

Moreover, he performed the essential task of converting part of the King’s revenue from kind into cash. Although in normal circumstances he still had a chance of good profits, the tax-farmer often appears in the papyri as a hunted debtor—a figure far removed from the dreaded vampire of Roman provincial administration. It was the local officials who tended to misuse their power and to become petty despots.

Nevertheless, at least under the early Ptolemies, the people do not seem to have been seriously unhappy. The fellahin had never known a better state of affairs and did not care much who it was that kept their noses to the grindstone. Nor did the Ptolemies and their advisers fail to recognize the importance to the royal revenues of preventing discontent. “As you travel about,” says the Chancellor’s circular to his subordinates, “try to go from one man to another and speak words of encouragement and make them all more cheerful.” As in any modem bureaucracy, public relations were not neglected.

More important still, he adds—what appears again and again in official instructions—that complaints must be looked into and abuses stopped. The peasants even preserved some kind of traditional right to strike, though its details are obscure. The large files of papyri containing complaints and details of lawsuits do not illustrate widespread injustice and discontent any more than (say) the files of a modem law-court would. They do, on the other hand, abundantly illustrate the Ptolemies’ care for the administration of justice, with each nation judged according to its own laws, and arrangements for conflicts between members of different races.

For Egypt had suddenly become a multi-racial society. For centuries as exclusive as Imperial China—thus the Greeks had only been allowed to settle in the treaty-port of Naucratis—it had been forced by the Persian conquest in the sixth century, and by its own attempts to regain its independence in the fifth, to open its doors to foreigners. We have seen that the independent Egypt of the fourth century came to rely more and more on Greeks. With the coming of Alexander and Ptolemy I, the last restraints were removed, and Greeks and other foreigners flocked to Egypt. Most of them came as soldiers.

As we have seen, soldiers were given allotments throughout the country: this helped to secure their loyalty and to ensure that of the natives at the same time. Their sons tended to succeed to their allotments as well as, at first, to their military duties. But financiers and businessmen also came, in order to seize the new opportunities: above all, the King himself always needed the help of these and other experts to run his bureaucratic economy. Then there were the technicians—men like Cleon in the Fayum—and the administrators: they were Macedonians and Greeks, speaking the language of the new King. (It is doubtful whether any Ptolemy before the last Cleopatra learnt to speak Egyptian.)

Before long there were groups of foreign settlers everywhere, often thoroughly mixed: the “Persians”—a privileged legal class, consisting, so far as we can see, of anything but Iranians—present a typical problem to scholars. The Greeks, however, were by far the most important of the settlers, and we may concentrate attention on them. They were not allowed to form city-states on the traditional pattern. Apart from Alexandria, which was a world of its own and was officially not regarded as part of Egypt, there were only two city-states: the old Naucratis in the Delta, and Ptolemais on the Upper Nile. Neither of them was large or particularly important.

For the Ptolemies disliked the traditional independence of the Greek polis: this, in fact, was where they chiefly differed from the Seleucids, who encouraged the city-state tradition and, by playing up their championship of it, succeeded in converting it into their most striking political instrument. In Egypt the Greeks settled in towns and villages with no more than local autonomy of a restricted sort. Yet, as far as they could, they cherished Greek institutions, especially the characteristic educational institutions (the gymnasion and the ephebate); and they often gave themselves the proud name of polis: City of Hermes, City of Apollo, even—noteworthy mixture of racial traditions!— City of Crocodiles.

The poet Theocritus, in his famous praise of Egypt (Idyll xvii), expresses the pride of these Greeks in their new country: “Countless countries, and countless tribes of men therein, with the aid of rain from heaven, bring their crops to ripeness, but none is so prolific as are the plains of Egypt when the over-welling Nile soaks and breaks up the soil, nor has any so many towns of folk skilled to labour.”2 (He puts the number of “cities” (poleis), with some poetic licence, at 33,333!)

We can see how proud Ptolemy and his Greeks were of their achievement, especially in the early days. Ptolemy sends distinguished visitors to see the work being done in the Fayum, much as nowadays delegations are taken to see a successful collective farm. Thus the local governor unexpectedly has to meet a well-known explorer; and Zeno, suddenly informed that envoys from the distant kingdom of Bosporus are already on the way, has to hurry preparations for their reception. But what was the attitude of the Government and of the settlers towards the natives?

We know that Greeks always tended to look down on “barbarians”—the more so, obviously, when the latter were a conquered people and the Greeks came as the agents of progress. There is evidence for this attitude, for instance, in the pathetic complaint written for a man who is ill-treated as a “barbarian,” because he cannot speak Greek. Yet there was little racial exclusiveness. For one thing, Greek nationalism—rather like that of the French in modern times—had a cultural rather than a racial basis. But there was also the important fact that the vast majority of the settlers were male.

Intermarriage is common from the start: before long Greek and Egyptian names and customs—notably sister-marriage, originally abhorrent to the Greeks, but popularized by the example of the Ptolemies themselves—are so inextricably intermingled that it becomes impossible to tell the origin of the writer of many a papyrus, however much he tells us about himself and his family. What applies to men applies to their gods as well. Thus, as early as 257, we find the “priests of Aphrodite” tactfully instructing Apollonius (in imperfect Greek) in a nice point of ceremonial concerning the burial of the sacred cow Hesis, who (they say) is Isis.

The great god Sarapis—probably a Hellenized form of the Apis bull who, after death, became Osiris—soon developed into what has been called the patron deity of the Ptolemaic Empire. (His cult was later to spread throughout the Roman Empire.) On the whole, although men still call themselves Greeks or Egyptians, institutions intermingle as freely as the actual races. Even the Greek and Egyptian systems of law (a naturally conservative branch of life), while remaining separate, strongly influence each other.

Nor were the natives excluded from the administrative services or from economic advancement, although it was certainly much more difficult for them and they never rose to the very top. As is to be expected, there is at first little evidence of communal tension between the Egyptians and the Greeks (or, for that matter, the Jews or other Asiatics). We have noticed one instance of it from a lawsuit; there are not many others. On the other hand, in many cases Egyptians and immigrants are found co-operating, and often we find both Egyptians and settlers on both sides.

Yet the fact was that the vast majority of the population was Egyptian, and that they were economically and politically oppressed by a small minority, in which foreigners, and particularly Greeks, were favoured, predominant and conspicuous. The priests, throughout Egyptian history, had traditionally tended to oppose the royal power. As the dynasty weakened, nationalist elements, chiefly among the priesthood, succeeded in raising rebellion, particularly in areas remote from the more cosmopolitan Delta.

As early as the second century, we find a monk of Sarapis complaining that he is persecuted because he is a Greek. From the second century to the end of the dynasty, repeated and prolonged dynastic troubles, with rival Ptolemies bidding for popular support, led to increased opportunities for the natives: in due course we even find an Egyptian as Governor of Upper Egypt, where Egyptian nationalism was strongest. But concessions only fed the hopes of the nationalists. By the beginning of the first century, native guerillas were at times effectively in control of Upper Egypt, until in 85 its venerable capital—“Thebes of the hundred gates,” as Homer had called it—was sacked, never to rise again.

It was only under the great Cleopatra, the first strong ruler for generations, that peace seems to have been restored throughout the country. Cleopatra, who could speak Egyptian, seems to have stressed the Egyptian element in her kingship. Thus she succeeded in uniting the races against the common threat of Rome.

But Cleopatra, obsessed with dreams of Egyptian greatness, became involved in Roman civil wars and fatally miscalculated. After the victory of Augustus and her suicide, the forms created by the Ptolemies easily adapted themselves to the Roman purpose, which was (as one scholar has put it) to milk Egypt for the benefit of Rome. Roman troops guaranteed order, and secure in their strength, the Romans introduced a regime of peaceful frustration and slow decline.

1 All dates are B.C.

2 Gow’s translation (Cambridge, 1952)