Black Birds of Doom

Boria Sax finds modern myth-making at work in the apparently timeless legend of the ravens in the Tower.

The famous ravens of the Tower of London add a primeval presence that the building itself - for all its being steeped in history, legend and ceremony - strangely seems to lack. Like everything else in the Tower, of course, they are heavily exploited by the tourist industry, but perhaps because the ravens do not themselves worry about commerce, they are largely immune to its power to trivialise or demean. The birds are cared for by the Yeoman Raven Master and allowed the run of the grounds, but their feathers on one wing are clipped to prevent them from flying far away. Yeoman Warders who work as tour guides tell visitors that nobody knows when the ravens first arrived at the Tower. What they really mean is that the ravens live in a world beyond time, the 'once upon a time...' of fairy tales.

Visitors are also told that the Crown and the Tower will fall if ever the ravens should leave - a story that is repeated in the flyer distributed free to tourists at the Tower. This announces on the cover that 'For over 900 years these unique guardians have patrolled the Tower of London' and goes on to say that 'these respected residents' have been protected by royal decree since the reign of Charles II.

And why did Charles II protect the ravens? The usual explanation, recounted in most popular histories of the Tower, is that the ravens interfered with the observations of the royal astronomer, John Flamsteed, at the time when the Royal Observatory was sited in the Tower. Flamsteed complained to the King, who agreed to get rid of the birds until he remembered, or was reminded of, an old prophecy that the kingdom would fall if the ravens left the Tower. Charles is then supposed to have said 'The Observatory must go to Greenwich and the ravens can stay in the Tower.'

When I first visited the Tower, it did not even cross my mind to doubt the antiquity of the ravens. I wrote to the authorities at the Tower to ask where I might find a copy of the decree of Charles 11, and was referred to the Tower's website, which simply repeated the familiar stories. Next, I searched in scholarly biographies of Charles II, but there was no mention of the ravens. I gradually became more sceptical about their antiquity.

The first written references I have come across to ravens being kept in the Tower date, to the 1890s. Ravens had disappeared from London for nearly half a century by then, and when a single raven mysteriously appeared in Kensington Gardens, a few journalists speculated that it had probably escaped from the collection of domesticated ravens in the Tower of London. I have tried to reconstruct the lore associated with the Tower ravens by searching for earlier references to them in old books of history, ornithology, folklore, and, most especially, in any early guides to the Tower that I could locate. I have looked at prints and drawings from the Middle Ages through to the nineteenth century. I have also spent days at the Tower of London, talking with the Warders and examining the available records. I have been unable to find any references, either literary or visual, to ravens in the Tower of London that predate the middle of the nineteenth century.

It is surely inconceivable that the many authors who have written in detail about the Tower would have failed to notice the ravens if they were present. If the ravens had been anything like those in the Tower today, they would have been begging for food, stealing baubles and occasionally pecking visitors. It is only through constant vigilance that the Yeoman Warders manage to keep the ravens safely in the Tower and more or less under control.

Harrison Ainsworth's novel The Tower of London, published in 1841, made popular the image of the Tower of London as a place of ceaseless plotting, imprisonment, torment, and executions. An illustration by George Cruikshank that accompanied the first edition of the novel shows dark birds, probably ravens, gathering at the scaffold of the Tower for the execution of Lady Jane Grey.

According to widespread folk traditions, the croaking of a raven presages death. In Shakespeare's Macbeth, for example, Lady Macbeth remarks as she plans the murder of King Duncan:

The raven himself is hoarse
That croaks the fatal entrance of Duncan under my battlements...

As the Tower of London began to attract crowds of visitors in the nineteenth century, the Warders were quick to exploit the connection between the ravens and violent death, which played to the Victorians' fascination with the macabre. In 1866 the keepers of the Tower erected a plaque on Tower Green to mark the place where the scaffold was supposed to have stood, even though there never had been a permanent scaffold in the Tower. In The Tower from Within (1919), the first book to describe the Tower ravens in detail, George Younghusband wrote, 'Round and about the site of the ancient scaffold, or sitting silent on a bench near by, may be seen the historic ravens of the Tower.' Yeoman Warders leading tours of visitors in the latter nineteenth to mid-twentieth century would describe, as indeed they sometimes do today, how the ravens used to gather at the scaffold and peck at severed heads. In the last decades of the nineteenth century, such horrors may have seemed too remote to provide more than a macabre thrill. But during the two World Wars, violent death became too familiar, even for middle-class civilians, to be received as innocent entertainment.

Younghusband gives a rather fanciful account of the disappearance of one raven from the Tower during the First World War, saying that it became so attached to the officers of the regiment in garrison that when they in their turn went to the Great War, he disappeared; 'whether to fight the Germans or because he could not bear to part from his friends has not been ascertained.' More likely, the raven was killed to stop its croaking. Many more anecdotes seem to have attached themselves to the ravens during the second World War. For example, soldiers quartered in the Tower were locked out if they failed to return by a certain time. One soldier, late back to barracks, tried to climb in by a drainpipe and fell to his death. A raven was heard to begin croaking from the battlements.

Two ravens were killed during the Blitz, and two more of the Tower birds, Mabel and McDonald, disappeared immediately after the end of the war. On July 8th, 1947, McDonald's decapitated corpse was found in a pit by the southwest corner of the White Tower, the oldest and most imposing part of the Tower of London. Mabel's remains have never been found. Assistant Raven Master Thomas Trent told me that a soldier once came to the Tower and sadly confessed to having killed a raven in his younger days.

In His Majesty's Tower of London (1950), a guide to the Tower written by the then resident governor Colonel E.H. Carkeet-James, we are told that meat is the ravens' favourite diet 'but little ofthat can now be purchased [in postwar Austerity Britain]; they seem to keep fit on fish, bread, and the cakes and sandwiches given them by the public.' Carkeet-James admits that the ravens were far from universally loved: 'They tear up the grass, flowers create an urge to destroy, they pick out the putty from the windows and the lead from the diamond leaded lights in the Chapel Royal of St Peter ad Vincula. Few motor cars are safe from their marauding and they find a strange fascination in ladies' silk stockings.' This is the first time that the ravens are mentioned in an official publication.

The earliest written reference that I have found to the legend that Britain will fall if the ravens leave the Tower is in a letter published in Country Life on February 3rd, 1955:

Sir, The interesting article on the menagerie at the Tower of London reminds me that the last survivors of an ancient tradition are the famous ravens. For centuries they were protected all over London by the populace as much needed scavengers, but the advent of sanitation signed their death-warrant. There are six ravens at the Tower, in the charge of a yeoman warder ... There is a vivid tradition that the loss of the Tower ravens would presage Britain's downfall. During the war there ran around a rumour that for five days no raven had croaked in the Tower, and it is a queer thing that all the six birds are young ones.

The myth linking the fate of Britain itself to the fate of the ravens in the Tower very probably developed during the second World War or shortly afterwards. No doubt, as so often happens, the peril that Britain faced, combined with a feeling of individual helplessness, inspired many people to look for portents. The legend may have been spread by Yeoman Warders partly to protect the ravens, since it made their calls into a reassurance that Britain was still strong instead of a harbinger of doom. Protecting the ravens was a response to a crisis rather than simply a royal whim. This makes the ravens a symbol of the greatest danger that the city of London has faced in modern times.

Ravens, once common throughout Britain, are now restricted to the west and north. Persecution by farmers and gamekeepers has driven them from many of their historic haunts. Thanks in small part to a breeding programme introduced at the Tower in 1987 their numbers are recovering. This programme could provide many valuable opportunities to educate the public about ravens and their lore. Perhaps, as raven numbers increase, some will return to London after more than a century and a half. Visitors to the White Tower may look up, see ravens in the sky, and feel confident that Britain is safe.

Dr Boria Sax teaches at Mercy College in White Plains, New York. His previous books include Animals in the Third Reich (2000), The Mythical Zoo (2001) and Crow (2003). He is currently writing a book on the ravens in the Tower of London.