The Begums of Bhopal
Princess Abida Sultaan, granddaughter of the last woman ruler of Bhopal, Begum Sultan Jahan, examines the rule of the Begum dynasty.
At a time when the revival of orthodox Islam and the status and role of Muslim women in modern society is capturing the attention of the world, the story of the Begums of Bhopal, and how during the last 200 years they overcame the prejudices, religious dogma and chauvinism of the period to play such a decisive and positive role in an otherwise male-dominated society, provides thought-provoking reading for the historian and sociologist.
Bhopal State was situated in the Malwa region of central India, and seemed destined to be dominated by women from its very inception. It was founded in 1709 by an Afghan adventurer, Dost Mohammed Khan, who first acquired the lease of a village called Bairasia which was to serve as a base. He then returned to his native Afghanistan to fetch his kinsmen and a trustworthy band of supporters to assist him.
His young wife, Fatah Bibi, was left behind in Bairasia at a period of particular turbulence and political unrest. The Mughal Princes were fighting amongst themselves, while their governors and lieutenants were busy converting their spheres of jurisdiction into personal kingdoms. The Mahrattas, Rajputs and Pindaris were also taking full advantage of the situation and annexing territory after territory. Hordes of thugs and marauders ravaged and plundered the countryside without restraint or fear of retribution.
It was therefore a considerable achievement for Fatah Bibi to hold Bairasia against these various warring parties and finally hand it back to her husband intact after his return. Bairasia then became the centre from which Dost Mohammed Khan carried out the initial conquests that led to the founding of Bhopal State.
In recognition of her inspiring faith and assistance throughout his career, Dost Mohammed Khan named the fort he built 'Fatah Garh' after her. Both Dost Mohammed Khan and Fatah Bibi worked side by side with the labourers throughout the construction of the fort. He also named the ensign of Bhopal 'Fatah Nishan' after her; an extraordinary tribute, coming as it did, 300 years ago, from an Oriental male.
At that time, the Bara Talab (big lake), near the site of the present-day city of Bhopal, was surrounded by thick bushes and shrubs, where Dost Mohammed Khan and Fatah Bibi frequently hunted. According to legend, the site of the city and fort was indicated to Dost Mohammed Khan by a saint in a dream. In due course, the modern city was built, with the Fatah Garh Fort standing majestically in the middle and the Fatah Nishan proudly fluttering on top of it: a worthy monument to the original builders of Bhopal. Dost Mohammed Khan and Fatah Bibi are buried side by side in the Fort. Their tombs survive, but the magnificent Fort itself has been recently demolished.
Dost Mohammed Khan died in 1740, having founded the dynasty which was to rule Bhopal for 240 years. He was succeeded by his son, Yar Mohammed Khan, whose wife, Mamola Bai, a Rajput lady renowned for her beauty and accomplishments, converted to Islam on her marriage, and from 1754 until her death in 1794 ruled Bhopal in all but name. Yar Mohammed Khan died in 1754 leaving an eleven-year-old son, Faiz, as his successor. Mamola Bai installed the child on the throne and made herself responsible for governing the state to prevent Faiz's relatives usurping his throne. The arrangement proved so successful that Faiz did not attempt to change it after he came of age, and retired into seclusion. He died childless in 1777 and immediately a controversy arose regarding the succession. Mamola Bai installed Faiz's younger brother Hayat, whereupon Bahoo Begum, Faiz's widow, staged a revolt and for nine years (1778- 87) formed a parallel government of her own.
Obviously, both sides had supporters from among the family. Hayat proved incapable of controlling the situation so Mamola Bai again intervened. She banished those of Hayat's cousins who were supporting Bahoo Begum's unlawful government, and tactfully persuaded Bahoo Begum to acknowledge her brother-in-law, Hayat, as lawful successor and ruler. The exiled cousins, led by Shareef Mohammed Khan, attacked Bhopal (February 24th, 1787) and were defeated at the battle of Phanda by the state army commanded by Mamola Bai. Their minor children grew up as orphans in exile and did not attempt to return to Bhopal until after Mamola Bai's death in 1794. In time, Mamola Bai began to be called Maanji Saheba (Madarn Mother) and was revered for her piety, wisdom, and skill in consolidating and retaining the state during a particularly turbulent period.
Unfortunately, her son, Hayat, seems not to have inherited his mother's statesmanship, and paid a heavy price for disregarding her policies. He allowed Shareef's son, Wazeer, to return to Bhopal after her death, and as a result Wazeer's influence and popularity grew steadily. Ultimately their heroic defence of Fatah Garh in 1813-14 against the besieging Mahratta forces of Scindia and Ragojee Bhonsla converted Wazeer and his son Nazar into heroes who were acclaimed the Saviours of Bhopal.
In 1817, Nawab Ghaus Mohammed Khan, Hayat's son and successor married his daughter Qudsia to Nazar. The over-confident Nazar, posing as the Ruler himself, concluded a treaty of alliance with the British Governor-General, Lord Hastings, in 1818. The treaty was not popular, and as a result a mysterious bullet ended young Nazar's life in 1819.
He left behind his eighteen-year-old widow, Qudsia, and his infant daughter, Sikandar. In the lawless, male-dominated society of the time, the most likely outcome of Nazar's assassination would have been that the control of the state would have been taken over by Nawab Ghaus Mohammed Khan, Qudsia's father, or usurped by some uncle, brother or cousin. Qudsia, however, declared that since the British had already recognised Nazar as the Ruler, it was his infant daughter Sikandar's right to succeed him and maintained that anyone who questioned this would have to contend with her. On Nazar's soyem (the ceremony held on the third day after death) she announced Sikandar's accession to the dumbfounded members of the family, Jagirdars, nobles and officials who had congregated at her residence for the last rites. She also obtained their signatures to an oath of allegiance to herself and Sikandar on a document which they all signed, fearful that their refusal would suggest their implication in Nazar's murder, and had it endorsed by the State Qazi and State Mufti. Among the signatories were her own brothers, the chief suspects. Thus, within three days of Nazar's death, his widow of eighteen had installed herself as Head of State, and all the combined protests, intrigues, threats, and attempts on her life failed to deflect her from her chosen path.
Qudsia, who had been deliberately kept illiterate and in strict purdah, now emerged without the veil, and took lessons in riding and the arts of war, to demonstrate her fitness to govern in turbulent times. Mughal authority had ceased and the British were still establishing themselves as the dominant power. Bhopal was surrounded by the territories of mighty Mahratta princes, the Scindias, Holkars, Bhonslas and Gaekwads, two of whom had all but conquered the state five years before, Yet once more the honour of the Fatah Nishan was guarded by a mere woman.
For her Hindu subjects, Qudsia Begum became the reincarnation of Maanji Mamola Bai; for the Muslims it was Bhopal's 'destiny' to be ruled by women; and for the historian it would prove to be the beginning of the 'Century of Women's Rule', for there was to be no male issue in the direct line of succession for four generations. During the eighteen years of her reign, Qudsia Begum defied and threatened, temporised and cajoled, procrastinated and equivocated, until, jealous of her popularity and exasperated by her success, the male members of her family began to clamour for British intervention on the pretext that Islam was in danger, since Islamic law did not acknowledge Women's rule. The British, anxious to uphold the cause of religion or for other reasons known to themselves gave their support to the men, and threatened to imprison both Qudsia and Sikandar unless Sikandar was married to her cousin Jahangeer and power transferred to him forthwith. Too clever to defy the growing British power, Qudsia Begum now chose discretion as the better part of valour and complied; only to prove her point later on.
Jahangeer proved a total failure as ruler. During his short reign of seven years, the only noteworthy incident on record is his abortive attempt in May, 1838, to kill his pregnant wife with a sword while she was asleep. Sikandar escaped and installed herself in the Fort of Islamnagar, seven miles from Bhopal. Three months later 'she gave birth to a girl, Shahjahan, on July 30th, 1838. As soon as she was able to resume her normal activities, which included riding, hunting and chaugan (a predecessor of polo), her favourite sport became terrorising Jahangeer with gunfire and arrows, or by cavalry charges. On one such occasion, Jahangeer was actually captured and imprisoned in the Fort of Ashta. He was released on the urgent intervention of Mr. Wilkinson, the British Political Agent. Sikandar, amused by Jahangeer's embarrassment, added insult to injury by going to release him personally, and like a chivalrous warrior shook hands with her captive, husband and Ruler.
Muslim rulers have on occasion abused their power by misusing women and conveniently justifying their shameful conduct by reference to Islamic law. Poor Jahangeer was no exception and indulged his 'sacred privileges' to such an extent that the people of Bhopal began to object strongly to his activities and besieged the British authorities with demands for his removal. Consequently, even his best friend, the Political Agent, had to warn him formally of the increasing public discontent caused by his maladministration. Death, however, intervened, Jahangeer died of his own excesses at the age of twenty-six on December 9th, 1844. His six-year-old daughter, Shahjahan, succeeded him, again with the proviso that power would be transferred to her husband when she married. Sikandar and her uncle, Faujdar Mohammed Khan, were appointed co-Regents by the British. However, corruption and incompetence led to Faujdar's own removal within a short time, and Sikandar alone held authority. Once again the government of Bhopal was in the hands of a woman.
Man frequently conquers and squanders; woman tends to possess and preserve. The glories of conquest are gained at the cost of human lives and massacres, generating hatred that lasts longer than the excitement and enthusiasm of victory. Peace, justice and fair administration have always endeared rulers to their subjects. Mamola Bai and Qudsia Begum had brought out these contrasts by their genuine and sincere concern for the welfare of their people, making them- selves accessible to them, listening to their grievances and, in a country always troubled by religious conflict, being impartial towards Hindus, Muslims, Christians and other communities alike.
Qudsia Begum, though illiterate, insisted on having all reports and state papers read out to her daily, when she would make a 'f' on the orders she dictated orally. The 'f' remained as effective as any elaborate signature or seal. Every afternoon she would sit under a particular khirnee tree outside her palace to meet her people and listen to their problems, No passes were required to approach her and no guards posted to protect her. She frequently went out in disguise to find out for herself how her orders were being executed by her officials and what her people thought of her government. She spun her own yarn and bought her personal requirements from the proceeds of its sale, considering it unjustifiable to use public money for her personal needs. Her Privy Purse went back as a permanent investment for the welfare of her subjects. The expenses for laying the Great India Peninsula Railway Lines in Bhopal were partly paid from her Privy Purse, and the Bhopal Rubats, where thousands of pilgrims have enjoyed free accommodation on pilgrimages for a century and a half in both Mecca and Medina, were constructed by Qudsia Begum. She constructed the Bhopal Water Works and had pipelines laid throughout the city, and made a perpetual endowment to ensure that water would always be supplied to her people free of charge. This continued until the state was handed over to the Indian Government. Mosques, wells and sarais (rest houses) were among her lesser charities. While I myself seldom heard anyone blessing Dost, Wazeer or Nazar for their heroic deeds and conquests, I have seen people lifting up their hands and blessing Qudsia Begum with tears of gratitude for their free water and free accommodation in Mecca and Medina.
During her reign, Sikandar Begum followed the example set by her mother with the added advantage of having been educated and groomed for her high position from birth. Guidelines to prevent future rulers from squandering public wealth on their personal whim were reduced to written laws. The Revenue System was brought up to date, lands demarcated, and the cultivator protected from being persecuted by state officials. Sikandar Hegum was a strict disciplinarian, a stern administrator and a determined organiser, who went into the minutest detail to achieve the highest standards of efficiency and justice. An astute diplomat, she was able to steer clear of involvement in the Mutiny of 1857 without compromising her Treaty obligations as a British ally.
Nevertheless, despite all the power, authority and prestige that Sikandar had gained during her Regency, her mother, Qudsia Begum was not satisfied. Had not the British unjustly deprived her daughter of her birthright? Had she not proved herself admirably worthy of her office? Had they, the British, not been guilty of breach of contract and faith, by violating the Treaty of 1818, and were they not insisting even now on power being transferred to Shahjahan's husband? Though the British did see her point, and conceded that as things had turned out the interests of the people would have been better served had they not intervened in favour of Jahangeer they still kept to their policy of non-interference in religious matters. Qudsia Begum, however, did not agree. She too based most of her political arguments in favour of Sikandar's rule on Islamic doctrine, insisting that none of the impediments quoted against Women's rule could be traced to the Quran. The Quran and the Prophet had not prescribed any particular system of government. How then could women have been excluded? The Quran, in referring to the Queen of Sheba, did not condemn her for being a queen, nor prohibit women from following her example in future. She argued too that the Companions of the Prophet would never have followed Her Holiness Ayesha, the Prophet's favourite wife, when she personally led her troops in the Battle of the Camel (c. AD 656), had there been the slightest doubt about the lawfulness of women's leadership.
The Islamic laws of inheritance were intended for individuals, not for institutions, governments or matters of state, which were subject to the welfare of the people and the requirements of the times. Men who wielded power inflicted double standards for the sexes, arrogating sacrosanct privileges to themselves and denying opportunities to women in the name of Islam. Otherwise, for example, the Mughal Empire should have been divided amongst the offspring of the Emperor according to the Islamic laws of inheritance, rather than left to the victors in the succession struggle.
With reference to the specific situation in Bhopal, she reasoned that the state judge and lawyer who had endorsed Sikandar's succession were as competent if not more so to give decisions on matters of Islamic law as those who were later on to issue legal decisions against her. It was also undoubtedly true that the role of the women of Bhopal had amply proved that the prejudices against women were unfounded, and, that given the training and opportunity, they were able to stand comparison with men. Finally, of course, there was the example of Queen Victoria! Was she not a woman ruling over millions of Muslims?
At last, after an eighteen-year long struggle, the condition that power would have to be transferred to the husbands of the Rulers was withdrawn by the British in 1855. They may well have thought that Qudsia Begum's fluent complaints had been brought to an end by this gesture, but Qudsia Begum remained adamant. Her Sikandar had been overlooked, and she would continue to fight for her rights to the last.
There was however no law or precedent by which the minor Ruler, Sikandar's daughter Shahjahan, could be displaced, and Sikandar installed as Ruler. Nevertheless, when Shahjahan came of age, she rose to the oecasion and abdicated in favour of her mother in 1860. Sikandar died on October 30th, 1868, having ruled for sixteen years as Regent, and eight in her own right. She was survived by her only child, her daughter Shahjahan, and her mother Qudsia Begum.
There was a marked contrast between the reigns of the Begums Sikandar and Shahjahan. While Sikandar had a dominating, almost masculine personality, Shahjahan was delicate and feminine. Sikandar administered with an iron hand and led her armies personally into battle, but Shahjahan preferred music, poetry, art and architecture, and built a magnificent palace, mosques and other buildings. Sikandar consolidated her domain by quelling dissent and subjugating opposition; her daughter enjoyed the fruits of her mother's dynamic reign in an atmosphere of security and continuity. With Shahjahan, Bhopal's royal court saw, for the first and only time, the atmosphere of austerity and simplicity replaced by the pomp and splendour normally associated with princely courts. Some saw signs of degeneration in Shahjahan's reign, others a period when a breath of joy and gaiety was let into the life of Bhopal.
Unfortunately, however, she exposed herself to bitter criticism by marrying a second time in 1871, and choosing for her husband her personal secretary, Sayyed Siddique Hassam, a man much below her station. This drove a wedge between her and her grandmother, Qudsia, and caused a prolonged estrangement from her only child, Sultan Jahan. Finally, her second husband caused so much friction between her and the British Government that it brought about her disgrace. Deprived of her administrative powers and reduced to a mere figurehead, she died in 1901, to be succeeded by her daughter, Sultan Jahan, who became the last woman ruler of Bhopal.
Sultan Jahan Begum's reign commenced with a challenge. The Treasury had been denuded before she had assumed power, and all the wealth accumulated by the self-denials and sacrifices of Qudsia and Sikandar had been squandered on the altar of magnificent indiscretions by Shahjahan and Sayyed Siddique. The independence of the Ruler had been forfeited to the British Government, while the prestige and dignity of the women of Bhopal needed immediate rehabilitation. Would she ever be able to restore the damage done during the thirty-three years of her mother's reign? Now in her mid-forties, Sultan Jahan had been forced into a life of isolation, banished from her mother's heart and court, and deprived of opportunities of learning about statecraft and administration, ever since the advent of her stepfather.
She felt desperately alone and inadequate for the gigantic task that faced her. The four pillars of strength, as she called them, had been snatched away from her by death. The first was Sikandar, her grandmother who died in 1868, who had brought her up, and whom she idolised. She had revered Qudsia, whose love and advice had sustained her after Shahjahan's second marriage. She had worshipped Queen Victoria, whom she insisted on calling 'my real mother'. She had relied upon her husband Ahmed Ali Khan, to guide her through all the vicissitudes of life. But he too had suddenly died in 1902, a few months after Sultan Jahan's accession to the throne. Now totally alone, she determined to dedicate her life to the reconstruction of the edifice built by her illustrious ancestors.
It would be impossible to compress her glorious reign of twenty-five years into an article of this length. It must be sufficient to say that she not only restored the former prestige of her ancestors, but became the most famous Ruler of Bhopal. Among her major achievements was the replacing of the feudal system of government by codifying the laws, establishing the High Court and other Courts of Law, a Judicial Council, a Legislative Assembly, with some nominated and some elected members, and a State Council to advise on her reforms. Though Qudsia Begum had given up purdah and Sikandar Begum had never been obliged to observe it, Sultan Jahan chose to retain the traditional garb of the strict Muslim woman and travel everywhere in a burqa.
Women's education and emancipation received her greatest attention: she presided over the first Meeting of the All India Women's Association, which was held in Bhopal and attended by delegates from all over India. She was the only woman to have been elected Chancellor of the Aligarh Muslim University, the centre of modern Indian Muslim thought and politics in the twentieth century. During her lifetime she wrote and published more than fifty books. Sultan Jahan finally abdicated in favour of her son, Hamidullah Khan, in 1926, and handed over an affluent, progressive, well-organised state to her only surviving child. The 'Century of Women's Rule', begun by the great Qudsia in 1819, came to a close and passed into the hands of a male after four generations. It is nevertheless fair to say that Qudsia's great-great-granddaughter, Sultan Jahan, still reigns over the hearts of those who had the privilege of knowing her.
Notes on Further Reading:
No one should miss the historical works of the Begums themselves: H.H. The Nawab Shahijan, The Taj-ul Ikbal Tarikh Bhopal; or, the history of Bhopal , H.C. Barstow, trans. (Calcutta, 1876), and H.H. Nawab Sultan Jahan Begum, An Account of my Life, Vol. I, C.H. Payne, trans. and Vol. II, Abdus Samad Khan, trans. (London, 1910 and Bombay, 1922). Other fascinating works in translation are: Nawab Sikhander Begum of Bhopal, A Pilgramage to Mecca , Mrs. Willoughby-Osborne, trans. (Culcutta, 1906), Sikhander Begum was the first Indian Muslim monarch to perform pilgramage, and H.H. Nawab Sultan Jahan Begum, Al Hijab or Why Purdah is Necessary (Calcutta, 1922). Two modern works are useful: Saeedullah, The Life and Works of Muhammed Siddiq Hasan Khan Nawab of Bhopal (Lahore, 1973) and U. Yanduvansh, 'Adminsitrative System of Bhopal under Nawab Sikhander Begum (1844-1868)', Islamic Culture , XLI, 1967, 4, 203-32.
-
Princess Abida Sultaan is granddaughter of Begum Sultan Jahan, last woman ruler of Bhopal. She is engaged in writing a history of Bhopal.

