Band of Brothers

Stephen Brumwell examines how the death of a charismatic young British officer 250 years ago this month – and the involvement of his two younger brothers in subsequent military operations in North America – had a lasting impact on Anglo-American history.

On July 14th, 1762, a new monument was unveiled in Westminster Abbey's already congested Nave. Its embellishments included a trophy of arms in fine white marble and the figure of a grieving woman. As the Boston Evening-Post proudly informed its readers some three months later on October 23rd, this mourner personified their very own province of Massachusetts Bay. The inscription told how the same colony,

… by an Order of the Great and General Court, bearing Date February 1, 1759, caused this Monument to be erected to the Memory of George Augustus, Lord Viscount Howe, Brigadier General of His Majesty’s Forces in America, who was slain, July 6 1758, on his march to Ticonderoga, in the 34th Year of his Age, in Testimony of the Sense they had of his Services and military Virtues, and of the Affection their Officers and Soldiers bore to his Command. He lived respected and beloved; the Public regretted his Loss; to his family it is irreparable.

Howe’s memorial, which cost £250 and was designed by James Stuart and sculpted by Peter Scheemakers, is located just inside the Great West Door. It is not the only monument within the Abbey to commemorate a young British soldier killed during the North American campaigns of the Seven Years’ War. Along the Abbey’s South Aisle, a distinctive pair of marble caryatids – life-sized and near-naked Eastern Woodlands Indian warriors complete with scalp locks, moccasins and tomahawks – flank the monument to Colonel Roger Townshend (1731-59), killed a year after Howe, during another, and this time successful, attack upon Ticonderoga, the fort (known as Fort Carillon by the French) on the western shore of Lake Champlain, in the disputed territory between New France and New England. Meanwhile, the North Transept is dominated by Joseph Wilton’s towering tribute to a better known British martyr of the annus mirabilis of 1759, Major-General James Wolfe (born 1727), the ‘hero of Québec’.

While Howe’s modest monument is neither the most striking nor impressive of this trio, it is surely the most poignant: unlike Townshend and Wolfe, Howe was killed not at a pivotal moment of victory, but on the cusp of catastrophic defeat; and his monument alone was conceived and funded by the colonists whom the British Army had been sent across the Atlantic to defend. This concrete gesture of gratitude would be remembered – with significant consequences – thirteen years later, when the once loyal province of Massachusetts Bay was the hub of colonial rebellion, and Britain and her North American colonies were at war.

But why was Lord Howe remembered so fondly by the inhabitants of Massachusetts? Of all Britain’s North American colonies, none had made a greater contribution, in both money and manpower, towards waging the bitter war against New France between 1755 and 1760. To the inhabitants of the Bay Colony, Howe epitomized a shared sacrifice. Yet there was another explanation for Howe’s extraordinary reputation – his personality and abilities, what they promised for the future, and the traumatic circumstances in which those hopes were dashed.

George Augustus, 3rd Viscount Howe (1724?-58), had arrived in Halifax, Nova Scotia in July 1757, with reinforcements intended to halt a depressing run of British defeats. In the following month, however, as the force in which he served was poised to attack the French fortress of Louisbourg on Cape Breton, the Anglo-Americans suffered yet another grievous blow: the outpost of Fort William Henry, at the head of Lake George, was seized by a French army under Louis-Joseph, Marquis de Montcalm (1712-59). The Marquis was unable to prevent his Indian allies from murdering scores of prisoners. Duly exaggerated by an outraged press, this massacre marked a nadir in the war with Canada.

By autumn 1757, such setbacks had dragged the reputation of British soldiers to an unprecedented low in the eyes of the colonists they had been sent to defend. Friction was only exacerbated by the disdain with which many professional British officers, not least their commander-in-chief, John Campbell, Lord Loudoun, viewed their amateur colonial colleagues.

Nothing in Howe’s background suggested that he would be any different. Howe was an aristocrat, an Irish peer whose mother was rumoured by that arch-gossip Horace Walpole to be an illegitimate daughter of George I. Educated at Westminster and Eton, Howe maintained this privileged trajectory when he joined the prestigious First Regiment of Foot Guards as an ensign in 1745. By July 1747, shortly after his election as MP for Nottingham, he was serving as aide-de-camp to the British Army’s Captain General, George II’s favourite son William Augustus, Duke of Cumberland (1721-65). 

Given his pedigree and connections, Howe too might have been expected to view colonial Americans with contempt, patronizing them as unsophisticated ‘children’ of the Mother Country. Yet the reverse was true. From the outset, Howe began winning the colonists’ hearts and minds, and in the months before his death, made a powerful and lasting impression upon them.

Young and debonair, Howe’s open, unaffected manner charmed all classes of American society. In her Memoirs of an American Lady (1808), Anne Grant, who as a child lived with one of Howe’s devotees, Margaretta Schuyler, identified the key to this unprecedented popularity. Anne, whose father was a British Army officer, only joined the Schuyler household at The Flats, north of Albany, in 1762, at the age of seven. But ‘Aunt’ Schuyler had never forgotten Lord Howe, whom she had loved like a son. Her vivid anecdotes made a deep impression on young Anne, who heard that Howe ‘laid aside all pride and prejudice, and gratefully accepted counsel from those whom he knew to be best qualified to direct them’.

This verdict is corroborated by tributes published in Howe’s lifetime, and after his death. A letter carried in the Boston News-Letter of July 27th, 1758, lauded Howe as an ‘excellent young Nobleman’, who, ‘at an Age when others go to learn the Art of War, at once appeared a finish’d statesman, and General; sober, temperate, modest and active, and did his Business without Noise’.

What particularly endeared Howe to Americans was his willingness to ‘rough it’ and endure hardship while seeking to learn lessons capable of turning the tide of the conflict. As the same letter noted, upon arriving in America, Lord Howe ‘entered into the Spirit of the Country, and the Enemy he was to engage’. This placed him at the forefront of a drive, instigated by Loudoun, to adapt the redcoats to the bewildering warfare of the rugged and forested wilderness stretching between the British colonies and Canada.

Since the loss of Fort William Henry, Loudoun’s advance units were based sixteen miles further south, at Fort Edward. From there, Howe accompanied the famous New England ranger Captain Robert Rogers (1731-95) on a scout northwards to French-held Ticonderoga, venturing into a no-man’s-land dominated by merciless guerrilla warfare between rival partisans. As Rogers recalled in his published journals, Howe was

... fond, as he expressed himself, to learn our method of marching, ambushing, retreating & c and, upon our return, expressed his good opinion of us very generously.

Howe was colonel of the 55th Foot and swiftly disseminated this knowledge within his own regiment, modifying his men’s uniforms, and training them for wilderness conditions.

In December 1757, when the ministry dominated by William Pitt implemented a sweeping new strategy intended to finish the American war in 1758, Colonel Howe received the local rank of Brigadier-General, and a vital role in the coming campaign. Aged thirty-three, Howe was among a team of young officers given fast-track promotion in the hope they would reinvigorate Britain’s stalled war effort. Howe was assigned to the campaign against Canada via the Lake George–Lake Champlain corridor, a route guarded by the fortresses of Carillon (Ticonderoga) and St Frédéric (Crown Point). This advance would coincide with a fresh strike against Louisbourg, commanded by Major-General Jeffery Amherst; officers allocated to that expedition included another newly-promoted ‘Brigadier-General in America’, thirty-one-year-old Colonel James Wolfe.

Wolfe, like Howe, had served in Flanders during the War of the Austrian Succession (1740-48); both had survived the bloody battle of Lauffeldt, outside Maastricht, in July 1747. Although no correspondence between them survives, the British officer corps was a close-knit fraternity, and Wolfe’s later comments suggest that they must have known each other. Wolfe was also familiar with Lord Howe’s remarkable younger brothers, Richard (1726-99) and William (1729-1814). In 1757, Wolfe had witnessed Captain Richard Howe of the Royal Navy in action off Rochefort, in the Bay of Biscay, and was impressed by his gallant conduct in command of the Magnanime. Along with ‘Black Dick’ Howe, as Richard became known, Wolfe, who had served as quarter-master-general on the botched Rochefort expedition, was one of the few officers to emerge from the affair with any credit. As Walpole observed, the fiery pair ‘soon contracted a friendship like the union of a cannon and gunpowder’.

James Wolfe was still better acquainted with William Howe. When Wolfe was lieutenant-colonel of the crack 20th Foot from 1750-57, William spent five years as one of his company commanders. At the head of the 58th Foot – which in Wolfe’s opinion became the best-trained battalion in America – he participated in the 1758 Louisbourg campaign. Wolfe respected and admired both Richard and William Howe, but he reserved his highest praise for their elder brother, lauding him as ‘the very best officer in the King’s service’.

Like Wolfe himself, George Augustus Howe excelled as a trainer and motivator of troops. That spring, while Wolfe and William Howe were sailing to join the task-force bound for Cape Breton, Howe was busy stamping his mark upon the powerful army of British redcoats and locally-raised ‘provincial’ troops that was slowly gathering for the projected push down Lake George. Although second-in-command to Major-General James Abercromby, Loudoun’s stolid replacement as commander-in-chief, Howe was the driving force behind the expedition.

Howe’s determined efforts to remodel his army for the challenges ahead attracted much attention in colonial newspapers. A letter from ‘a Gentleman in New York’, dated May 31st, 1758, and printed in the New Hampshire Gazette of June 16th, was typical:

I need not inform you, I suppose, how justly Lord Howe is celebrated here for his robust Soldier like Constitution, his bold enterprising Spirit, and every other Military Accomplishment; with how much Care he has been forming his Regular Troops to the Method of Bush-fighting all this Season … His Soldiers love and fear him, and willingly comply with his Commands, because he first sets them the Example – What great Things might not a few Officers like Lord Howe effect, with an Army of such Men!

At Howe’s insistence, the long skirts of the soldiers’ coats were cut short to ease movement through the brush. Their hair too was cropped, and Howe led the way, sacrificing ‘a fine Head of Hair’. His Lordship likewise toted his own provisions – the same hard bread and salt pork issued to the rank and file – and, having banned washerwomen from following the army, went ‘himself to the Brook’ and scrubbed his own linen. As a letter dated June 12th, printed in the Boston News-Letter of July 6th reported with approval, such a Spartan regimen had done nothing to dent Howe’s popularity with his officers: on the contrary, he was ‘very much esteemed’ by them.

By the early summer of 1758, Lord Howe had become the talisman of the Anglo-American war effort: soldiers and civilians alike pinned their hopes of victory upon the dynamic brigadier.

On the hot morning of July 6th, 1758, advance elements of Abercromby’s 15,000-strong army landed at the foot of Lake George. Their first objective, Ticonderoga, was defended by fewer than 4,000 men under Montcalm. Splitting into four columns, the Anglo-Americans began threading through thick woodland towards the fort. They collided with a small French detachment that had expected the British to land further up the lake, and was attempting to regain Montcalm’s lines. Outnumbered, the French were cut off and eliminated. Anglo-American losses were trifling in number – less than twenty – but momentous in result: almost the first shot fired killed Lord Howe. According to his aide-de-camp, Brigade-Major Alexander Monypenny, the ball punched through Howe’s lungs, heart and backbone. ‘I was about six yards from him’, Monypenny wrote five days later, ‘he fell on his Back and never moved, only his hands quivered an instant’.

Howe’s death was widely regarded as a catastrophe. Another eyewitness, Captain Hugh Arnot of Gage’s Light Infantry, reported that Howe had fallen, to ‘the unspeakable Grief of the whole Army’. As Captain Joshua Loring of the Royal Navy noted, the consequences were felt immediately: ‘so far things had been properly Conducted and with Spirit’, he wrote, ‘But no sooner was his Lordship Dead, than everything took a different turn and finally ended in Confusion and disgrace’. The probing advance promptly stalled and, as rumour rippled back down the columns, disorder spread among the jittery troops.

In the day required to restore discipline, Ticonderoga’s defenders received a crucial respite: they used it to finish fortifying the peninsula upon which the fort was built, working feverishly to construct an eight-foot high log wall, itself screened by a mass of tangled and sharpened branches. Montcalm’s aide-de-camp, Captain Louis-Antoine de Bougainville commented:

The disheartened English gave us twenty-four hours delay, and this precious time was the saving of us and the colony.

Howe’s loss hit Abercromby hardest of all. As the general confessed to Pitt, Howe was ‘universally beloved and respected throughout the whole army’. For Abercromby his ‘untimely fall’ caused both personal grief and professional consternation, with disastrous results. Convinced that reinforcements were hurrying to Montcalm’s aid, on July 8th Abercromby authorized a frontal assault upon the Marquis’ formidable position. Marching forward without an artillery bombardment to cover them, his infantry were slaughtered in a futile attempt to break through. At a cost of about 400 casualties, the French killed and wounded nearly 2,000 of their assailants.

This crushing defeat dealt a heavy blow to Anglo-American morale, already shaken by the shock of Howe’s death. As the Boston News-Letter reported on July 13th, before the ensuing debacle was known,

The losing [of] Lord Howe is paying too dear for the advantages we have yet gain’d; for nothing can compensate for so dear a Sacrifice, but the total reduction of Canada.

Anne Grant’s Memoirs give a vivid account of the grief unleashed by the news. When a galloping rider from the north called out that Howe was killed, Madame Schuyler ‘broke out into bitter lamentations’. This outburst had ‘such an affect [sic] upon her friends and domestics that shrieks and sobs of anguish echoed through every part of the house’.

Hints of these dismal developments had reached Amherst’s army, 500 miles to the north-east, on July 27th, the very day that his men entered the battered walls of Louisbourg, which had capitulated after a stubborn defence. Writing to his father on August 7th, James Wolfe left no doubt of his own feelings:

My Lord Howe, the noblest Englishman that has appeared in my time, and the best soldier in the army … Heavens, what a loss to the country! The bravest, worthiest, and most intelligent man among us!

William Howe was inconsolable, as Wolfe testified: ‘For several days he refused to eat, and could not bear to have anybody near him, even of his most intimate friends’.

Hopes of ending the American war in 1758 died with Howe. Yet Louisbourg’s capture, which gave access to the St Lawrence River, and the heart of New France, offered some compensation. 

Brigadier Wolfe’s performance was widely praised. As the newspapers reported, he had distinguished himself throughout the Louisbourg campaign, leading the first hazardous landing from open boats on June 8th, and energetically prosecuting the ensuing siege. Britons on both sides of the Atlantic were hungry for a hero: although one had been lost, another had now taken his place.

Wolfe’s emergence as a trans-Atlantic celebrity underpinned his promotion to Major-General commanding the land forces for the crucial 1759 expedition against Québec. His subordinates during that campaign included Colonel William Howe. In the early hours of September 13th, 1759, it was Howe who led the light infantry in a daring commando-style assault up the cliffs above Québec that paved the way for Wolfe’s victorious fire-fight on the Plains of Abraham.

By undermining French power in North America, Wolfe’s victory had a seismic impact. With the long-standing threat from Canada removed, Britain’s American colonists could finally give serious thought to their own independence. Yet it can be argued that George Howe’s legacy for Anglo-American relations was, ultimately, no less decisive than Wolfe’s.

Howe’s posthumous reputation among the colonists resonated with his surviving brothers. It was Richard, now 4th Viscount Howe, who supervised work on the monument unveiled in 1762. Deeply touched, he intended to erect an obelisk as a reciprocal gesture, expressing not only ‘his love and Veneration for his Brother’s Virtues, but … his Gratitude and Respect for that Public and Patriot Voice, whose generous applause has adorn’d their memory’.

The affection shown by Massachusetts Bay towards his brother exerted a powerful emotional hold over Richard; this sentimental bond held strong enough to shape his subsequent attitude and actions as the crisis escalated. In 1766, Richard Howe, as treasurer of the navy, was among only a handful of key office holders willing to receive the petition of the Stamp Act Congress; at Christmas 1774, with war looking ever more likely, he met Benjamin Franklin, London agent for Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, Georgia and New Jersey, spending weeks in a futile effort to persuade him to work for an accommodation.

On the eve of the final rupture, William Howe shared his brother’s slant on the Anglo-American dispute. He too retained deep affection for Massachusetts, and a belief that negotiations could prevent an irreparable breach. Like his brother, however, William Howe was also a career officer, ambitious for personal glory and professional distinction. In January 1775, while declaring in public that he had no desire to serve in America, in private he informed the prime minister, Francis Lord North, and the American Secretary, William Legge, 2nd Earl of Dartmouth, of his readiness to sail to Boston as second-in-command to General Thomas Gage. With Gage temperamentally unsuited to quelling colonial rebellion, Howe had a good prospect of taking his place, and so influencing British policy.

Major-General Howe reached Boston in May 1775 in time to command the assault upon Bunker [Breed’s] Hill on June 17th, a murderous engagement in which he maintained the family tradition of leading from the front. Howe swiftly replaced Gage as commander-in-chief, and in the following summer led Britain’s invasion of New York. By then, General Howe was one half of a ‘peace commission’ dispatched to America by North; the other was his brother Richard, now a vice-admiral in command of the Royal Navy in North American waters.

As peace commissioners, the Howes interpreted their mandate to secure the colonies’ outright submission in their own way, alternating negotiation with displays of force. That July, while British forces slowly coalesced on Staten Island, Admiral Lord Howe vainly attempted to open discussions with the rebels’ commander George Washington. After William Howe’s rout of Washington’s forces on Long Island in late August, a victory limited by his reluctance to maintain pressure on them, Lord Howe tried again: on September 11th, 1776, he organized a peace conference on Staten Island attended by three congressmen, including his old friend Franklin and another radical, the Massachusetts lawyer John Adams. The trio returned unimpressed by Howe’s statement that the colonists’ grievances could only be considered after they had surrendered, but struck by his explanation that his family’s connections with New England left him with a strong personal desire for peace.

In 1776 the Howes confronted their American opponents with decidedly mixed feelings: had they been contentedly fighting the French – as both brothers demonstrated during the previous war – they would have shown no such hesitation in fulfilling their mission. As Ira D. Gruber has argued in a classic study, the Howes’ conflicting dual roles as military commanders and peacemakers compromised Britain’s war-effort at a crucial moment: their reluctance to deliver a knock-out blow during the summer of 1776, when the inexperienced Washington was willing to risk his unseasoned army in a stand-up fight, proved costly. Between Christmas 1776 and early January 1777, Washington exploited this unexpected reprieve to launch devastating ripostes at Trenton and Princeton, morale-boosting victories that ensured the Revolution’s survival.

Exactly how far the conciliatory stance of William and Richard Howe was motivated by memories of their long-dead brother is debatable; likewise the extent to which their conduct in 1776, compared with other factors, influenced the outcome of the Revolutionary War. Yet the story of the Howe brothers, and the implications of their close relationship for Anglo-American history, suggests that it would be unwise to neglect the role of sentiment in shaping events: voted in all sincerity, with no ulterior motive in mind, Massachusetts Bay’s £250 was – by any reckoning – money well spent. 

Dr Stephen Brumwell is a freelance writer living in Amsterdam. He is currently working on a biography of George Washington for Quercus.