Art for the People
G. Waterfield and Nicola Smith look at an initiative to blend industrial living and artistic appreciation in Victorian Britain.
In an area of London seldom if ever visited by tourists, close to Camberwell Green, stands on the Peckham Road the imposing turn-of-the-century red brick building of Camberwell Art School and, behind the same façade, the South London Art Gallery (since 1992, the South London Gallery). This gallery enjoyed a brief period of prosperity and activity in the 1890s, but during this century its role has been variously and confusingly interpreted. Recently recast as a centre for advanced contemporary exhibitions, a Whitechapel Art Gallery of south London, it retains a seldom-exhibited collection of late Victorian paintings and works on paper, as well as Southwark's topographical views and numerous British twentieth-century works. The exhibition currently on view at the Dulwich Picture Gallery gives the public the opportunity to see examples of the founding collection, and to assess the socially revealing history of the gallery's inception.
The name of the gallery, laying claim to the whole of London south of the Thames, reveals the vision of the gallery's founder, William Rossiter. Writing on the gallery's twenty-fifth anniversary, Rossiter told of his enthusiasm for the work of the first Working Men's College, founded in 1854, and his realisation that many of the students lived in South London:
which is, as I then perceived for the first time, the vast dormitory of the great majority of the men who work in central London ... From this came the idea of a college in South London, in the midst of the workers...
It was from this college that the gallery developed, and Rossiter's dream was to see it grow into nothing less than:
... the National Gallery of South London ...placed where it is most wanted, where the daily lives of the people most need such refreshment, and where the great artisan class, whose work beautifies the wealthier part of the metropolis, live with so little beauty either natural or derived from art.
Rossiter became a teacher at the Working Men's College and it was here that his ideas for a similar institution in South London took shape. The South London Working Men's College opened in 1868 in Blackfriars Road. In 1878 the college moved to Kennington Lane, it was extended to include a free library, the first in South London. The Library opened in October 1878, and a few months later Rossiter added to it '... by borrowing pictures to cover the walls during the summer months'. The gallery was born. As time passed the focus of the institution shifted in the direction of the visual arts. As Rossiter explained:
... so many friends lent pictures, and so many were allowed to remain, that the exhibition intended for a few weeks has now been in existence for about fourteen years, and has become so important that the name of Free library has been replaced by that of South London Fine Art Gallery.
The original educational role was never forgotten, however, and in 1882 a series of Sunday lectures was inaugurated which remained an important feature of the gallery's work. Rossiter's initial aim was to bring books to those who had no other opportunities to see them. At a time when boroughs were gradually taking up the right to set up free libraries on the rates, he sought to encourage councils to do so through the example of the libraries he set up himself, often using his own books. It was his policy not to stay in an area once the Free Library Act had been adopted. When Lambeth adopted the Act in 1884 the gallery moved to Battersea and in 1887 to Camberwell:
... a thoroughly artisan and neglected neighbourhood, remarkable for the number of its public houses and the vigour of its language, for the long hours of labour and the utter absence of any means of education beyond the day schools; for the enormous number of its children, and for their uncivilized behaviour ...
In these early years the gallery could boast success. The challenges and rewards were described by Rossiter in 1890:
When we opened new exhibitions ... for the first six months our lives were filled with terrors. There was a general supposition amongst the people that every body who came into the neighbourhood wanted to get something out of: it, and – well we did get something. We got cabbage stumps shied at our heads; the children ... came and swore at us, and little boys of three or four years would want us to fight. I have been invited by a gentleman of four to go out and have my head punched. But the benefit of a permanent institution such as ours, going on year after year, is made apparent. We have been able to help those very swearing young monkeys who came to us, we have been able to watch them year after year, because they came day by- day. We have been able to watch them growing up into youths, and after twenty years' working I can trace at least a hundred people who have passed through the gradations of beginning by ... throwing cabbage stumps at our heads, then becoming interested, regular attendants at our lectures, and growing and developing into really thoughtful people.
The reward was a spectacular rise in attendances. The number of visitors increased from 27,000 in 1881 to 58,000 in 1886 and 86,500 in 1887. At a time when much concern was expressed over the dreariness of urban living, and over the failure of state or church to provide for the physical or spiritual needs of the working-class urban population, a number of galleries and exhibition places were set up, under the influence of John Ruskin, in the poorer areas of great cities. The most notable of these were the Manchester Art Museum devised in the late 1870s and established at Ancoats Hall in 1886; the art exhibitions organised from 1881 at St Jude's National School in Whitechapel; the Ruskin museum near Sheffield, at Walkley (1878); and the South London Art Gallery. At a time where there was enormous general interest in visiting museums, these galleries were extremely popular, regularly attracting a large public but of a specific sort: middle-class audiences did not visit these places other than in a philanthropic role as 'helpers'.
These galleries and museums should be related to a much wider social initiative in late Victorian Britain: the efforts by representatives of the upper and middle classes to organise the leisure of the working class by offering educational, cultural and sporting opportunities. Frequently such activities were provided by 'settlements' or 'missions', close in inspiration and style to colonial enterprises. Walter Besant's tone in writing about the East End is characteristic of the sense purveyed by those involved of venturing into the unknown: he wrote of 'the far East, in that region of London which is less known to Englishmen than if it were situated in the wildest part of Colorado, or among the pine forests of British Columbia'. These endeavours involved the creation of communities in deprived areas in which middle- class representatives of universities, men or women, and usually young, would settle. These settlements were related to the 'philanthropic' gallery: the Barnetts set up Toynbee Hall, with the intention of creating a university of East London, while from 1891 Ancoats Hall accommodated a university settlement. The South London Art Gallery prided itself on its accessibility: open on Sundays ('This is the only Collection of Art Works in all London that is open on Sunday' proclaimed the gallery's Weekly Notes), open in the evenings, positively welcoming to children. It represented the culmination of a long transition from the private to the public institution. It also represented a complex internal history. It was driven by the force of a united group of people, and lacked a single-minded purpose. It combined, at least in aspiration, three types of institution: the working men's college or People's Palace, the collection of applied arts for craftsmen and the gallery devoted to the fine arts.
Rossiter's endeavours at the beginning of his career to create libraries and debating clubs were part of a much broader movement. The tradition of the mechanics' institute, with its library and exhibitions, had in the 1880s been overshadowed by a more ambitious undertaking, the People's Palace in the Mile End Road. This enterprise was intended as a centre of pacifying educational and social activity. Closer to Camberwell, the Royal Victoria Hall in Waterloo, the origin of the present Old Vic Theatre, was set up by Emma Cons in the 1880s. What she described as 'The People's Palace for South London' organised not only dramatic and musical entertainments in the Temperance Music Hall but regular lectures, which attracted around 1,500 people on Saturday nights. Backstage, a 'College for Working Men and Women' was organised, named after the philanthropist Samuel Morley: this offered classes in scientific subjects, a gymnasium and a library. Its aspirations were not lost upon Rossiter.
The ideal of the Working Men's College remained strong throughout the phases of the South London Art Gallery. In the premises on the Peckham Road, the first major building was the library and lecture room intended to serve 'the literary and scientific part of the work, which had for a time been overshadowed by the growth of the art gallery'. The aim was to provide a general cultural education, including music.
The second important aspect of the South London Art Gallery was its role in technical education and in the improvement of popular taste. Just as the Ancoats Museum had included Model Rooms designed by W. A. Benson, on a less ambitious level Morris furniture was put on view at Camberwell. It was the relationship with the Technical School which developed this aspect of the galleries most fully. Following an initiative from the new Borough of Camberwell to set up 'a school of Arts and Crafts', the new school was opened in 1898. Encouraged by Passmore Edwards, it was intended to give practical training. Although instruction in drawing was offered, the principal objective in the early days was to train crafts people such as builders, decorators, 'Designers in Wall Papers, Textiles and Furniture, and Embroiderers ...'. In this task, the galleries were to play an active part: students were encouraged to copy from the exhibits, and educational exhibitions were arranged. This close association between gallery and school maintained the primarily educational purpose that Rossiter had envisaged, but directed it more specifically towards the applied arts.
For a few years in the 1880s and 1890s, the South London Art Gallery illustrated the powerful working of philanthropic connections in the Liberal establishment. Rossiter and Frederic, Lord Leighton (President of the Royal Academy), assembled an influential group of benefactors and artists. The artists who supported the gallery mostly belonged to the circle around Leighton and Burne-Jones. Their friends included both Royal Academicians and numerous artists associated with the Grosvenor Gallery.
Women played an important role in the activities of the new gallery, in a way not possible at such conservative institutions as the Royal Academy. Of the thirty-eight artists listed as donating their own work in 1895, nine were women. The gallery attracted the support of a number of women interested in women's rights such as Anna Swanwick, author and translator, whose interest in social questions included raising the moral and intellectual tone of the working class as well as the education of women. For women wishing to exercise a talent for organisation, it gave the chance to play an important part in the administration of an institution made respectable by charitable and non-financial associations.
Rossiter and Leighton's support was strengthened by a network of well-connected philanthropists and politicians. Apart from Baroness Burdett Coutts, these included Sir John Lubbock, later created Lord Avebury, Liberal MP and Vice-Chancellor of the University of London, banker and President of the Society of Antiquaries and the Royal Society; and Octavia Hill, Secretary of- the Working Men's College from 1856, pioneer of housing reform and a joint founder of the National Trust. The fund-raising activities of the gallery represented an equally remarkable activity: the 1890 Report of a Public Meeting, held on behalf of the gallery, listed among the contributors three Rothschilds and the Duke of Westminster, an enthusiastic art collector, who regularly opened Grosvenor House, with its outstanding gallery, to parties of craftsmen on educational visits.
The supporters of the gallery included the most advanced artistic circles of the time: the interest in the gallery shown by Crane and Burne-Jones involved prominent patrons of the Arts and Crafts Movement in its affairs, notably the Earl of Carlisle and the Hon. Percy Wyndham. Other supporters included the venerable J. C. Robinson, former curator of the South Kensington Museum; and the collector E. A. Ionides, who left his pictures to South Kensington and was also a patron of the Webb-Morris circle. Other celebrities included J. W. Cross, who made a donation in memory of his wife George Eliot; and Mr and Mrs Rudyard Kipling. Like the Whitechapel, the Camberwell institution was active in invoking the support of glamorous figures: leading representatives of the stage – a newly respectable profession – who gave help included Herbert Beerhohm Tree.
The confusion of purpose associated with the early days of the South London Art Gallery has over the years borne ambiguous fruit. For many years after the Second World War it served neither as a centre of activity for the local population nor as a service for the adjacent art school; it housed, and still does, three incongruous collections – the Victorian works of art, a twentieth-century British collection associated with artists working at Camberwell, and the Southwark topographical collection – which cannot be shown on anything more than a very occasional basis. Though now its future is brighter, it is unlikely, in any but the most general way, to be able to fulfil its founders' ambitions.
The work of these pioneers’ wealthy and cultivated people organising cultural manifestations in order to manipulate and pacify a potentially troublesome working class – is easily criticised from a modern viewpoint. The tone of the literature which accompanied the exhibitions is often patronising: the idea of cultural colonisation may well be found offensive today. There is no doubt, however, that the art exhibitions and the lectures received an enthusiastic response from their intended audience; and in the field of education, especially visits to museums and galleries for schools and the organisation of loan services, these institutions, and especially the Ancoats Museum, played a lasting role.
The aims of the organisers were often more radical than might at first appear. Both the Barnetts and many of those involved with the Ancoats Museum in Manchester had a defined political agenda, seeing the institutions that they set up as a first step in bridging the chasm between rich and poor, and denying any intrinsic difference between social classes. The South London Art Gallery provided a neat microcosm of the conflicts embodied by these institutions: the efforts of its initial founder, William Rossiter, to set up a gallery and library to educate the people, became in the hands of the well-meaning artists and benefactors who took control of its affairs a quite different place, where the presentation of fine art was of prime importance. The galleries have all gone, or have been radically changed; but the achievement of their founders, even if they did not find the answers to their questions, was to have raised the questions at all.

