Glasgow - A Moving Portrait

The historian of a city is presented in an acute form with the question common to all historical writing: to what extent is history narrative? Or the question may be reversed: is it possible to stop the clock and paint a portrait which escapes being an illusion? There are some forms of history which lend themselves to linear treatment. Of course in any historical narrative different things are going on at the same moment, though they cannot be narrated simultaneously; nevertheless a battle, for instance, or a diplomatic negotiation, may be seen to have a beginning, a development, and a result. At the end of the day one army holds the field, and the other has withdrawn, or a treaty has been signed. No such conclusion is possible in urban history; it is always and forever in the making.